Individual Assignment
Case Study-quoted from the required text book
Blake Mycoskie and TOMS
By age 29, Blake Mycoskie had already started four businesses. He got
the idea to start his fifth business on a trip to Argentina. Blake observed
that many people were wearing alpargatas soft casual canvas shoes and
he thought they would sell in America. But he also realized that there
were also many poor people without any shoes who had blisters, sores,
and infections. So he decided to help.
Back home in America, Blake got involved in a volunteer shoe drive to
ship shoes overseas. But he realized that there was a need for a constant
flow of shoes and that even a nonprofit organization couldn’t be very
sustainable through simply donations. He was also an entrepreneur and
wanted to make money. So Blake came up with the idea of being a
social entrepreneur by combining business and charity to help others and
make the world a better place.
Blake Mycoskie founded TOMS, which stands for TOMmorrowS
shoes, in 2006. He developed the One for One business model for every
pair of shoes TOMS sells, it gives away a free pair to a child in need.
But as with entrepreneurial new ventures, it wasn’t easy. In fact, Blake
was told that he didn’t understand the shoe industry and that his business
wouldn’t be successful. But that didn’t stop Blake. To date, TOMS has
given away more than 10 million pairs of shoes.
Blake realized that he couldn’t just buy the alpargate shoes. They needed
to be more stylish, comfortable, and durable to sell in the United States.
So with no knowledge of the shoe industry and not speaking Spanish, he
returned to Argentina to find a local partner, and teamed up with shoemaker Alejo for help. Together they developed a prototype and Blake
brought 250 pairs home to Los Angeles.
Blake ran a focus group by inviting a bunch of friends, mostly women,
to his place. He told them his story and One for One, and they discussed
the potential market and price for the shoes and where they could be
sold. They loved the story, bought a pair of shoes, and spread the word.
Blake went to retail stores and told his story and tried to get them to sell
TOMS, but he got lots of rejections. Blake would tell his story to anyone
who would listen. He would wear two different shoes just to get people
to talk to him so he could tell his story. Blake’s first two big breaks
came when American Rag agreed to sell TOMS and the LA Times ran
his story in the newspaper. Orders started pouring in. So Blake started
the business on a shoestring budget by using his apartment and three
interns he found through Craigslist.
Blake went back to Argentina to give away free shoes and develop a
supply chain of TOMS shoes. Blake believes that success is more than
status and money and that it’s about contributing to the world and living
and working on your own terms. He has personal, professional, and
philanthropic success. Today, TOMS gives free shoes to 60 countries.
Blake has expanded his social entrepreneurship mission to include
writing a book, Start Something That Matters, to inspire others to
contribute to the world. He also expanded his unique One for One
business model to include TOMS Eyewear, helping save and restore
sight for those in need. TOMS Web site (www.toms.com) includes the
Marketplace where people can shop for a variety of other products and
contribute to funding education. TOMS has Giving Partners to increase
its charity, and it has given millions to nonprofit organizations. To
encourage social entrepreneurship, TOMS develops ways to use its
platform to support their ventures. In addition, the Start Something That
Matters Foundation has begun to help innovators bring their ideas to life.
1. What do you think Blake Mycoskie’s personality traits are for each of
the Big Five dimensions?
2. Which of the traits of effective leaders would you say has had the
greatest impact on Blake Mycoskie success a tom?
3. Which motivation would McClelland say was the major need driving
Blake Mycoskie to continue to work so hard despite being worth
millions of dollars?
4. Is Blake Mycoskie ethical in business? Which level of moral
development is he on?
Managerial Leadership 343
Individual Assignment -Case Study
Name:
Section:
Student ID:
Instructor Name:
Max Marks: 10 marks
Guidelines for a written report of the case using the following
format:
Part I
1. Background statement:
•
•
What is going on in this case as it relates to the identified major problem?
Summarize the scenario in your own words.
• Briefly describe the organization, situation, who is involved, who decides what
and so on.
2. Identify the Major problems and Secondary issues:
•
•
•
Identify the major and secondary problems.
What are the real issues?
What are the differences?
3. Organizational Strengths and Weaknesses:
•
•
Your focus here should be in describing what the organization is capable of doing
with respect to addressing the problem.
Identified strengths and weaknesses should include those at the managerial level
of the problem.
4. Alternatives and recommended solutions:
•
•
Describe the 2 to 3 alternative solutions you came up with.
What feasible strategies would you recommend?
5. Answering the case study discussion questions?
1
PART II:
1. In all pages (Arial, Font size, Heading 12, 1.5 Spacing)
2. The Total number of Pages for the case study, should not exceed more
than 3 pages.
3. The due date of submitting the Case study is in week 7 (both hard as well
as electronic copies). Late submissions will not be accepted.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2
Course: Managerial Leadership 433
Instructor: Dr Rasha Alghafes
Year: 2018-19
Semester: 2nd
RUBRICS FOR CASE STUDY/LEVELS OF ACHIEVEMENT (Total 10 Points)
Sl.No
Basis/Criteria
1.
Introduction (20%)
2.
Analysis and evaluation of
issues/problems (20%)
3.
Identifying Organizational
Strengths and Weaknesses (20%)
4.
5.
5.
Recommendations on effective
solutions/strategies (20%)
Writing skills and flow of ideas
(20%)
Total mark:
/100
__/10
EXEMPLARY (4Points)
ACCOMPLISHED (3 Points)
EMERGING (2 points)
BEGINNING (1 Point)
This section was well
organized, presented the
main focus on the study
section, included adequate
content, summarized
information when needed.
Presents an insightful and
thorough analysis of all
identified issues/problems
; includes all necessary
reasons
Make appropriate and
powerful connections
between identified
issues/problems and the
strategic concepts studied
in the course readings and
lectures; supplements
case study with strengths
and weaknesses, relevant
and thoughtful research
and documents all sources
of information
Supports diagnosis and
opinions with strong
arguments and well
documented evidence
The concept of the case
study section had one
limitation
Included irrelevant
information, failed to
explain concepts
Presents a thorough
analysis of most of the
issues identified missing
some necessary reasons
The concept of the
case study section had
one limitations,
Had a disjointed focus,
Incorrect information
The content of the case
study section was not
clearly written and
difficult to understand
Presents a superficial
or incomplete analysis
of some of the
identified issues; omits
necessary calculations
Make little connections
between issues
identified and the
concepts studied in the
course readings;
supplements case
study if at all with
incomplete research
and documentation.
Fails to make an
analysis/argument at all.
Argument fails to answer
the issue. No creativity
expressed.
Fails to use any evidence
from the text reading;
uses no appropriate
sources
Little action suggested
and / inappropriate
solutions proposed to
the issues in the case
study.
Fails to come up with any
suggestion or
recommendation to the
issue in the case study.
Writing is very little
focused, rambling or
contains errors ;lacks
organization and
follow some
guidelines
No proper flow of idea
and language. Writing is
not organized. No
guidelines followed
Demonstrates clarity,
conciseness and
correctness; formatting is
appropriate and writing is
free of grammar and
spelling errors
Make appropriate but
somewhat vague
connections between
identified issues/problems
and concepts studied in
the course readings and
lectures; demonstrates
limited command of the
strengths and weaknesses
tools studied; supplements
case study with limited
research.
Supports diagnosis and
opinions with limited
reasoning and evidence;
presents a somewhat one
sided argument;
demonstrates little
engagement with idea
presented
Occasional grammar
grammar or spelling errors
but still a clear
presentation of ideas; lacks
organization
Purchase answer to see full
attachment