Cover Letter Checklist and Rubric
Rubric
Criterion
(Score 0 if element
is absent)
Below
Expectations
(2)
Meets
Expectations
(3)
Exceeds
Expectations
(4)
Score
The Cover Letter Checklist: What to Include and Exclude
✓ The same full contact information as your résumé. Include your name, email address, a
link to your LinkedIn profile or, if you have one, your personal website, and your GitHub.
✓ A consistent look. Make sure that your résumé and cover letter match in style and
presentation.
✓ Paragraph sections. Include a salutation, opening (one paragraph), main body—modified
60-second pitch (one paragraph), and closing (one paragraph).
o Salutation: This is your greeting (such as Dear Ms. Debra Smith). Try to get an exact
name instead of using To Whom It May Concern.
o Opening (Paragraph One): State the position you are applying for and why you are a
great fit. Demonstrate to the reader your strengths in a few powerful lines. Ask for
an interview.
o Main body (One Paragraph): Get to the nitty-gritty about how and why you are best
for the job. Look at the qualifications, experience, and skills outlined in the job
description and show the reader how you match these. Explain some of your
greatest past accomplishments. Focus on the company’s requirements and what it
needs. When writing this section, always keep the following question in the back of
your mind: Why should we hire you?
o Closing (One Paragraph): This should be a quick summary of what you talked about
in the body to reiterate what you bring to the table. Thank the employer and suggest
a meeting. Sign off in a polite and professional manner. Ask for the interview again
(CALL TO ACTION).
✓ The right amount of white space—not too much or too little.
✓ The length is ONE PAGE (one full page including your contact information and that of the
recipient).
✓ No spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors.
✓ Personalization. The letter must include a salutation and be addressed to the right person.
✓ Your key skills as they relate to the position being applied to, written in the same way that
they are written in the job posting to increase your chances of making it through the
applicant tracking system (ATS).
✓ The reasons why you would be best for the position. Include knowledge, skills, and
experience as they relate to the job posting.
NOTE: Each and every cover letter you write must be tailored to a specific job and employer. You
cannot reuse a cover letter or work from a template, simply changing words here and there. The
more customized your letter is, the greater your chances will be of making it through the system,
getting your letter read by the hiring manager, and getting an interview.
1
Cover Letter Checklist and Rubric
What to Omit and Avoid
✓ Avoid clichés, such as the following:
o “To Whom It May Concern”
o “My name is . . .”
o “I am writing to express my interest in . . .”
o “I’m probably not the best candidate, but . . .””I am applying for the role of [title] at
[Company] . . .”
✓ Never reuse a cover letter. Start fresh each and every time. It’s okay to use a guideline, but
never use the same cover letter twice.
✓ Don’t be vague. Be specific, especially in outlining your skills as they relate to the position.
✓ Don’t repeat your résumé. Instead, discuss your work history and emphasize any major
accomplishments that relate to the position you’re applying for. Expand on certain aspects in
detail to tell a story about your accomplishments, but don’t tell the reader what he or she
already knows.
Design Elements
✓ Be consistent. Make sure that your résumé and cover letter match in style and
presentation.
✓ Keep it short. One page. The hiring manager will admire your ability to be concise.
✓ Keep it succinct. Try to use short sentences instead of long ones, and try to keep each
paragraph to five lines or fewer.
✓ Use numbers and metrics (KPIs). These really make your accomplishments stand out and
help draw the reader’s eye.
✓ Use boldface if you want to emphasize something, instead of underlining or italics.
✓ Avoid graphics, pictures, images, tables, etc.
✓ Use a common document type. Unless the employer asks for a specific format, prepare
your cover letter as a Word document (.doc or .docx). Word documents, as opposed to PDFs
or other file types, are the most common and are therefore the easiest to be
emailed/attached, opened, and read.
✓ Format appropriately. Use a standard business letter format, listing your name and
address, the date, and the recipient’s name and address first, followed by the salutation and
substance of the letter. The main body of your letter will vary from industry to industry, but
a rough outline looks like this:
✓ Include white space (or negative space). This refers to margins (the areas between the
main content and the edges of the page), gutters (the vertical space between columns), and
the spaces between lines of type and graphics or figures. Having a balance between white
space and content will keep your cover letter from looking cluttered.
✓ Use an appropriate font style, size, and color. Use a font that is easy to read and that
doesn’t distract from your message. Fonts such as Arial, Calibri, Verdana, Times New Roman,
Georgia, Lucida, Tahoma, or Trebuchet were designed for the web and are commonly
accepted. The font size should be between 10 and 12 point, and the color should be
consistent throughout (black).
✓ Use one-inch margins all the way around your cover letter. This will ensure that no
information gets cut off if a paper copy is printed.
Spelling, Grammar, and Punctuation
✓ Attention to detail. Spelling and grammar are important indicators of a candidate’s
attention to detail; they highlight defects instead of spotlighting qualities. It is nearly
impossible to recover from spelling errors in your cover letter.
✓ Action words. Use words that convey action, such as advised, examined, oversaw,
prepared, resolved, and compiled.
2
Cover Letter Checklist and Rubric
✓ Consistency. Be consistent with your punctuation throughout. This includes using only
single or double quotation marks, using the serial comma consistently, and using only
straight or curly quotes.
✓ Acronyms. Always make sure to spell out any acronyms in full upon their first use,
followed by the acronym in parentheses.
✓ Editing. Make sure to take the time to thoroughly edit and proofread your cover letter.
Even the smallest spelling mistake can have a disastrous effect, so pay extra attention when
reading through this document. A hiring manager who sees mistakes in your cover letter
won’t take you seriously and will think you are lazy, which also makes it more likely your
application will be rejected.
✓ Punctuation. Make sure to use punctuation marks properly. Know the difference between
a hyphen (-), an en dash (–), and an em (—) dash; when and how to use a semicolon (;); how
to use a comma properly (,); and that a period (.) goes at the end of each complete sentence.
✓ Capitalization. Capitalize words correctly. Do capitalize names; proper nouns; names of
cities, states/provinces, and countries; languages; company names; brand names; and
months. Do not capitalize job titles (unless they come before a name); college/university
majors (unless it’s your degree title); important-sounding career words that aren’t proper
nouns; seasons; or directions.
✓ Style. Be formal in your letter, but don’t be afraid to let your personality shine through. Be
true to yourself in your language and tone.
Bonus Tips for an Awesome Cover Letter
✓ Get to know the company’s culture (read its website; look at its LinkedIn page) so you can
write like one of the team members and show that you’d be a perfect fit.
✓ Regardless of whether you’re fresh out of university or 10 years into the workforce, try to
focus on your work experience, not your education.
✓ Be a storyteller. If possible, tell a story. Explain how you came to learn about this
company; what brought you here? Try to connect in a way that makes you stand out from the
rest.
✓ Show your future employer that: a) you’re going to excel in the position; b) you’re friendly
and likable, and you get along well with others; and c) you’re going to be a great fit.
✓ Write like a real person—don’t be robotic and overly formal, but also don’t be super
excited and so over the top that you seem disingenuous.
✓ Read over the company’s website and try to write in its “voice.”
✓ Show interest and enthusiasm about what you have to offer and what the company can
offer you.
✓ Stay positive and focus on your strengths; don’t apologize for not having the right
experience or exact educational background.
✓ Use an active voice instead of a passive voice.
✓ Be yourself, not fake or too formal. You want to appear sincere, approachable, and real, so
make this come through in your writing.
3
Purchase answer to see full
attachment