Business Finance
Business law questions about The United States Constitution and Judicial System

Question Description

Anwer the following questions with supporting evidence.

  • Sue Smith purchased a house in Baltimore County, Maryland across the street from a wooded area owned by the County.Within a year of Sue’s purchase, the County converted the wooded area to a landfill.The landfill accepted hazardous waste and other trash that could be harmful to the environment.Sue made multiple complaints to the County Executive, John, to no avail.Thus, Sue filed a lawsuit against the County alleging violations of federal environmental laws pertaining to groundwater contamination and air pollution. (15)
    • In which Court(s) may Sue file her lawsuit?What factors must Sue consider? Provide the full rationale for your answer and include every Court that you believe is proper. (THE EXACT NAME OF THE COURT IS NOT REQUIRED, JUST THE TYPE AND LEVEL.)
    • Does Sue have standing to sue? Why or why not?
    • If either litigant is dissatisfied with the outcome of the case, based on your answer(s) to Question 1a. what would be the next step(s)?
  • Assume that the Court in which Sue files requires mediation or non-binding arbitration.Also assume that the mediator or arbitrator decides that Sue’s legal argument is sound and decides in her favor.The County disagrees and desires to challenge the mediator/arbitrator’s decision.(5)
    • What options are available to the County?
  • Assume that Sue’s case proceeds to trial.Sue testifies that she is certain that her drinking water has been contaminated and is making her sick.She describes her water as looking, tasting and smelling different since the landfill was built.Sue also testifies that the landfill emits a terrible stench and that she is fearful that she will develop lung cancer if the landfill continues polluting the air.The County’s expert witness testifies that the Landfill is operating in accordance with federal environmental laws.Further, the expert states that in his opinion and based on similar situations in California, Texas and New York, the air and water impacted by the Landfill cannot lead to negative health complications in humans. (10)
    • Is Sue’s testimony admissible?Why or why not?
    • Is the expert witness’ testimony admissible?Why or why not?
  • Assuming that the Judge is satisfied that the County’s expert witness is an expert on federal environmental law, may the Judge accept the expert witness’ testimony as the proper interpretation? (5)
  • After the testimony of the Landfill’s President, Mary, Sue goes on a rampage.She sends emails to the County Council describing John as “the biggest liar in the world” who is “intentionally polluting my air and water to either kill me or force me to sell my property.”She describes Mary as a “whoring floozy” who “only has her position because of sexual favors to John.”On Sue’s Facebook page, she repeats the same statements and wishes that “the lying, evil County Executive and his mistress get what’s coming to them.They definitely both deserve to die for what they have done to the citizens of Baltimore County.”Mary’s Husband learns of Sue’s comments and files for divorce from Mary. (15)
    • Does John, the County Executive, have any legal claims against Sue? Why or why not?
    • Does Mary, the Vice President, have any legal claims against Sue? Why or why not?
    • Does Sue have any defenses to legal claims made by either John or Mary?Why or why not?
  • John accuses Sue of threatening his life and the Baltimore County Police go to Sue’s home to arrest her at 1:30 pm.Sue refuses to open her door.So, the Police force their way into her home and arrest Sue.They take her computer back to the Police Station with them as evidence of Sue’s alleged crime.After Sue is arrested, she is questioned by the Police Chief.She confesses to him that she is guilty of threatening the County Executive and shows him the Facebook post and other online statements authored by her.The Police Chief tells Sue, “You are in BIG trouble.I hope you know a good lawyer!”The next morning, Sue is allowed to use her one phone call to contact an attorney.
    • Sue’s attorney believes that the Police have violated her constitutional rights.What constitutional claim(s) does Sue have?Provide a detailed rationale for your answer.

Final Answer

Please find attached. Let me know if you need edits.


Sue Smith vs. Baltimore County Case
Student Name




Part one
This dispute centers on the landfill that is operated by Baltimore County and Sue Smith
as a private citizen whose land is near the landfill. When Sue Smith bought her land, the landfill
was not yet there. Instead, the land that was converted into a landfill was wooded. Due to the
landfill being near Sue Smith land, she is justified to sue the county for accepting hazardous
waste and other trash that were harmful to the environment. The best court that she can file a
lawsuit against Baltimore County is District Court which is going by the fact that district court
judges have the ability to try cases either civil or criminal.
Sue Smith should consider various factors before determining to file a lawsuit in the
District Court. First, she should be satisfied that the landfill did not comply with the district’s
health regulations. Second, Sue Smith must ensure that th...

peachblack (34254)
New York University

Top quality work from this tutor! I’ll be back!

Just what I needed… fantastic!

Use Studypool every time I am stuck with an assignment I need guidance.

Similar Questions
Related Tags

Brown University

1271 Tutors

California Institute of Technology

2131 Tutors

Carnegie Mellon University

982 Tutors

Columbia University

1256 Tutors

Dartmouth University

2113 Tutors

Emory University

2279 Tutors

Harvard University

599 Tutors

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

2319 Tutors

New York University

1645 Tutors

Notre Dam University

1911 Tutors

Oklahoma University

2122 Tutors

Pennsylvania State University

932 Tutors

Princeton University

1211 Tutors

Stanford University

983 Tutors

University of California

1282 Tutors

Oxford University

123 Tutors

Yale University

2325 Tutors