Discussion topic response and 2 Feedbacks on other discussion responses for business and finance question

Oct 19th, 2015
Price: $20 USD

Question description

Read the bellow discussion topic. Your job is to respond to the discussion topic (3 SOLID PARAGRAPHS WITH REFERENCES) and respond to comments 1 & 2- different perspectives from other people (2 PARAGRAPHS FOR EACH COMMENT WITH REFERENCES, IF USED).


M.K. Gallant is the president of Kranbrack Corporation, a company whose stock is publically traded. In a meeting with stockholders at the first of the year, Gallant stated profits would rise by 20%. It is now November, Stan Richart, the vice president in charge of the technologies division sees making the target profit for his division will be difficult. He directed the following:

  • Discretionary expenses be delayed until the beginning of the new year
  • On December 30th, he discovered that a warehouse clerk had ordered $350,000 of parts in early December. Even though the parts were not needed until February of the next year. These parts are ordinarily expenses when received and Richart ordered them sent back. The parts have been received and the supplier will not accept returns. 
  • Gallant ordered the receiving dock to change the dates on all products received between December 25th and December 31st to the first week in January.


  1. Are the actions ethical? Explain why or why not.

On the surface this small sample size of executive decision making seems totally unethical. But, consider the decision making process of M.K. Gallant. In my opinion Gallant is taking a calculated risk. 1) Gallant must prevent the exodus of stockholder monies. 2) Poor supply chain management (warehouse department) may do more damage discrediting the company to future investors. 3) Gallant must keep his company operational, profits at a desirable and realistic level to attract future investment, and his employees employed. His decision is warranted and justified in changing the dates on the documents in the receiving dock. The parts are still company property/inventory and any fines that may or may not be imposed by the SEC will not exceed future potential earnings or affect current company operations.

2.  Does the general management philosophy and accounting policies at Kranbrack discourage ethical behavior by their managing by the numbers?

Negative, corporations operate to increase their bottom line. Regardless of what their public relations agenda is. We must understand corporations are functioning entities whose sole purpose is to make money for the company, investors, and continue sustainable growth. The situation in Kranbrack should lead to companywide improvements in supply chain operations. Safeguards should be implemented for supply orders exceeding certain dollar amounts and supply orders put in the last quarter of the financial year need approval from upper management. Decisions in corporations are based by the numbers regardless of what the situation is.


  1. Are the actions ethical? Explain why or why not.

Mr. Richart is facing a dilemma. The actions may or may not be ethical from a business ethics perspective depending on the language of the policy. If the policy clearly states that parts are expenses when received, then Mr. Richart's directives are in violation of the company’s policy.  If the policy has language that says parts are ordinarily expenses when received and any exceptions must be approved by management, then Mr. Richart's directives are within the policy and there is no violation because Mr. Richart has a management role.

 Another aspect to consider is the gray area which involves the term "ordinarily."  Mr. Richart may rationalize his actions because he perceives the business situation he faces is "not ordinary", and therefore, the ordinary policy does not apply.  Using this rationale, he may contend that his actions are not in violation of company policy and he may assert that he is acting in the company's best interest by helping the company reach its goal.

  1. Does the general management philosophy and accounting policies at Kranbrack discourage ethical behavior by their managing by the numbers?

Yes, the general management philosophy and accounting policies at Kranbrack discourage ethical behavior by their managing by the numbers.  The president of the company, Mr. Gallant, is putting out a headline number "profits to rise by 20%" that financial analysts on Wall Street love to see and regurgitate in their headlines, articles, financial estimates, and financial reports in traditional and social media.  Mr.Gallant may be seen as a "earnings hero" especially if he is making his profit statements during an economic recession.  He may have a fame motive and yearn for the spotlight "to be noticed, to be wanted, to be loved, to walk into a place and have others care" (Carey, 2006).  By publicizing the profit target, Mr. Gallant is putting the managers under tremendous pressure to "make the numbers" and has created artificial dilemmas that otherwise would not have been.  He is putting the managers in an awful position.  Putting  managers in awful positions is a springboard for unethical behavior.  Mr. Gallant should seek his fame in other ways.

Tutor Answer

(Top Tutor) unicew
School: UC Berkeley

Studypool has helped 1,244,100 students

Review from student
" Excellent job "
Ask your homework questions. Receive quality answers!

Type your question here (or upload an image)

1828 tutors are online

Brown University

1271 Tutors

California Institute of Technology

2131 Tutors

Carnegie Mellon University

982 Tutors

Columbia University

1256 Tutors

Dartmouth University

2113 Tutors

Emory University

2279 Tutors

Harvard University

599 Tutors

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

2319 Tutors

New York University

1645 Tutors

Notre Dam University

1911 Tutors

Oklahoma University

2122 Tutors

Pennsylvania State University

932 Tutors

Princeton University

1211 Tutors

Stanford University

983 Tutors

University of California

1282 Tutors

Oxford University

123 Tutors

Yale University

2325 Tutors