STUDENT 1:
For this week's forum, I have decided to focus on Qatar. When searching for an area to research, I found
that, according to National Geographic, Qatar's per capita carbon emissions are the highest in the world
and three times as high as that of the United States (National Geographic 2019). The citizens of Qatar
are provided with free water and electricity, which contributes to tremendous energy demands as the
water has to be desalinated and air conditioners are excessively used (National Geographic 2019). In
fact, the energy demand in Qatar grows by 7 percent each year to run the desalinators, air conditioners,
and natural gas production equipment that the economy depends on (National Geographic 2019).
Current projections assert that if every person on Earth lived like Qataris, the Earth would need 5 times
the resources it currently has to sustain that sort of lifestyle (National Geographic 2019). While the
country experienced tremendous economic growth and increases in education as a result of the
exploitation of resources/environmental degradation, the citizens face a serious health threat from air
pollution (Lanouar et al. 2016, 1). Qatar's level of air pollution far exceeds the World Health
Organization's recommended standards (Lanouar et al. 2016, 2). Asthma in particular is highly prevalent
in Qatari children (Lanouar et al. 2016, 2). Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, among many other
respiratory diseases, can affect the population due to these excessive levels of air pollution (Lanouar et
al. 2016, 2). These threats of air pollution, excessive energy consumption, and environmental
degradation, therefore, contribute to the increased economic insecurity of Qatar by threatening the
ecosystem, sustainability, survival, and quality of life for Qataris (APUS 2019). They pose grave concern
for the amelioration of natural resource scarcity, the maintaining a healthy environment, the
amelioration of environmental degradation, and could be a cause for social disorder or conflicts with
other gulf states (Glenn et al. 1998, 19). As we read about, environmental strains transcend a state's
borders/sovereignty (Tuchman-Mathews 1989), and given Qatar's close proximity to a number of states
(some of which it already has existing tensions with), the environmental security of Qatar is of upmost
concern and needs to be addressed for the sake of its citizens' wellbeing, the conservation of resources,
and preventing escalation with other states.
Devin
References
APUS. "Lesson 1: An Overview of Environmental Security." APUS, 2019.
https://edge.apus.edu/portal/site/406274/tool/cab9c42a-523d-4c0f-a59c605f5f0d6257/ShowPage?returnView=&studentItemId=0&backPath=&errorMessage=&clearAttr=&sour
ce=&title=&sendingPage=3115422&newTopLevel=false&postedComment=false&addBefore=&itemId=1
1718606&path=push&addTool=-1&recheck=&id=. (accessed May 7, 2019).
Glenn, Jerome, Theodore Gordon, and Renat Perelet. "Defining Environmental Security: Implications for
the U.S. Army." Army Environmental Policy Institute, (December 1998): 1-45.
https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a593191.pdf. (accessed May 7, 2019).
Lanouar, Charfeddine, Afnan Yousef Al-Malk, and Khloud Al Karbi. "Air Pollution in Qatar: Causes and
Challenges." College of Business and Economics, Qatar University, Vol. 1, Iss. 3, (2016): 1-7.
http://www.qu.edu.qa/static_file/qu/colleges/cbe/documents/research/Charfeddine_2016.pdf.
(accessed May 7, 2019).
National Geographic. "Ten Countries with the Biggest Footprints: Qatar." National Geographic, 2019.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/sustainable-earth/pictures-ten-countries-with-thebiggest-footprints/. (accessed May 7, 2019).
Tuchman-Matthews, Jessica. "Redefining Security." Foreign Affairs, Vol. 68, Iss. 2, (1989).
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/1989-03-01/redefining-security. (accessed May 7, 2019).
STUDENT 2:
Good afternoon class!
For our first forum for this class, we have been asked to pick a state or region and discuss three serious
threats to the environmental security of inhabitants. In our lesson, it speaks about environmental
security is one of the issues that requires transnational cooperation. The United Nations recognize that
climate change is one of the defining issues of the world at this time and are attempting to take drastic
action to help the world we know today, to become a better world tomorrow (United Nations).
I would like to focus on Alaska for the three serious threats. The first threat of climate change that is
playing a role on Alaska is the continuous thawing of the Arctic. The last four years have been the
hottest years on record, and the winter temperatures in the Arctic has raised 3 degrees Celsius since
1990 (United Nations). With the melting of the ice caps in the Arctic, it has contributed directly to the
coastal erosion, sea ice retreat and permafrost melt. A fourth impact of the higher temperatures have
been wildfires in Alaska. Wildfires have destroyed more forest in Alaska than any other decade on
recorded, and these numbers are estimated to double by 2050 (Moss).
The coastal erosion caused by the ice melt is affecting the coastal storms. The ice that was once there as
a buffer against the waves, no longer is. The fishing in Alaska is also being affected, in particular the
crabbing season, that is now shorter by a month on both ends of the season (Livingston).
The threat behind the permafrost melting, which is the always-frozen ground that underlies much of
Alaska, is the release of the carbon from the plants underneath the ice. Scientists have estimated that
the process of permafrost thawing could contribute as much as 1.7 degrees Fahrenheit to the already
prevalent global warming (Fountain).
Best of luck with the first week of class, class! I hope you all have a great weekend!
Tyler
AMU. IRLS409 Lesson Week 1. 2019.
"UNITED NATIONS Climate Change - Summit 2019." United Nations. Accessed May 09, 2019.
https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/.
Moss, Tyler, Caitlin Morton, Tyler Moss, and Caitlin Morton. "14 Places Disappearing Because of Climate
Change." Condé Nast Traveler. April 20, 2018. Accessed May 09, 2019.
https://www.cntraveler.com/gallery/10-places-to-visit-before-theyre-lost-to-climate-change.
Livingston, Ian. "In Alaska, Climate Change Is Showing Increasing Signs of Disrupting Everyday Life." The
Washington Post. May 08, 2019. Accessed May 09, 2019.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/weather/2019/05/08/alaska-climate-change-is-showing-increasingsigns-disrupting-everyday-life/?utm_term=.8ffb739db668.
Fountain, Henry. "Alaska's Permafrost Is Thawing." The New York Times. August 23, 2017. Accessed May
09, 2019. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/08/23/climate/alaska-permafrost-thawing.html.
STUDENT 3:
Hello Professor Ruff and Class,
We have been tasked to discuss a set of situations that we deem prevalent on the topic of environmental security.
I have been having problems with the log in, so I am taking things from memory in hope that I recollect accurately
enough. Then when I tried to verify which reference belonged to one I was using, it popped up a window with a big padlock on it.
Apparently that was not the one, but there are umpteen listed and the name doesn’t seem to coincide with any I find matching the
link. I am correct in knowing it does belong to the situation and too many details to explain further.
I chose Haiti as a country in distress based on some past information while studying my Peacekeeping Logistics class.
The approach was about logistics, but the concerns were still there in that there were strategies that had to be dealt with in regard
to helping countries and how to go about it.
In the case of Haiti, there were a lot of natural catastrophes from earthquakes. In turn this affected the economy greatly.
It also affected the culture. The approach to my other paper to do with Haiti was similar and contrasting.
In terms of natural catastrophe, to do with our topic is more to do with climate change being the most prevalent and
associative point relating to the economic and cultural business.
I derive quite a bit of information through reading our first week’s lesson along with the Chapter 12 reading of Human
Security (American Public University System, 2019).
I am roughly putting this topic into a capsule form when mentioning climate change, economic growth and culture
effects, of course. To summarize, climate change is mentioned in the above-mentioned reading of Chapter 12, that changes of too
much rain, or too little, result in floods or drought; that in turn effects economic growth due to agricultural practices, slowing of
crops, food production, sales and trade. Another example how it is affected is when stock has to be sold or dies due to drought.
Naturally stock is sold if it can be understood in time by the farmer that he cannot continue to keep the stock because of the
environmental conditions of water shortages, or lack of food.
The third unseen, but felt consequence occurs is the cultural changes that people are put through when conditions like
drought or floods cause a migration to other areas that bring a disconnection from the familiar social culture people are
accustomed to. It is considered of great importance that people are allowed to maintain their own culture and to have it returned
to them as soon as feasibly possible. Also people move from rural to urban areas for better working and living conditions, from
Chapter 12 FAQ12.4 (Adger, et al., pp 761-775).
Haiti had so many earthquakes natural catastrophes that it has kept their people in an upheaval. Neighboring states
would have people come in to work but they would return to their state. The economic flow went out of the country rather than
ever being able to stimulate the weakened and vulnerable economy. In turn, another thing that occurs due to a weakened state
situation is divisions of groups and government policies slowing processes that also affect conflict resolution. There was a lot of
corruption going on in Haiti. Some of it was also to do with human trafficking, if I correctly recall (Oswald-Spring, 2011).
To sum it up from here, this week’s study encompasses the basis of our course with regard to how humans are affected
with the environment and with their security within it. As mentioned, I chose climate change, economic growth and cultural
effects, or simply cultures as the main three, although not the only three things going on in these matters by any means. Climate
Change seems to be a primary source that effects so many other things. In that is shown that it effects economic growth exampled
with too much rain, floods or not enough, causing drought and wind erosion, thus, effecting the agriculture, food, and making a
living. In turn, these affect the living circumstances of economic change and also of migration that moves people from one area
to another. The migration of people from their local homes and groups of culture are affected (Adger, et al., pp 761-775;
American Public University System, 2019; Oswald-Spring, 2011).
Regards,
R. Kathie McClung
Bibliography
Adger, W. N., J. M. Pulhin, J. Barnett, G. D. Debelko, G. K. Hovelsrud, M. Levy, U. O. Spring, and C. G. Vogel. Human
Security. In: Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part A: Global and Sectoral Aspects.
Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA: Cambridge University Press, 2014.
Chapter 12: Human Security pp. 755-791
American Public University System. "WEEK 1: An Overview of Environmental Security: Defining and Contextualizing
Environmental Security." Lecture, IRLS409 - Environmental Security, American Military University/American Public
University System, Charlestown, West Virginia, May 2019.
Oswald-Spring, Ursula. Human, Gender and Environmental Security: A HUGE security. 2011.
Purchase answer to see full
attachment