ENGH 044 Shooting the Elephant Essay

User Generated

Puryfrn26

Writing

ENGH 044

ENGH

Description

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Name _________________________________ I.D. Number _______________________ Project 3 Evaluation 33 ENGH 044 060 Twelfth Grade English 2 Be sure to include ALL pages of this project (including the directions and the assignment) when you send the project to your teacher for grading. Don’t forget to put your name and I.D. number at the top of this page! Project 3 is worth 50 points. It is worth 12 percent of your course grade. For this project, you will choose one option. A rubric is provided so you know how you will be graded and what is required. Please look over the rubric as well as reading the comments it provides. Also, review the appendix in this course for more about writing essays, thesis statements, paragraphs, MLA style, and conventions. Cultural Analysis In this project, you will examine the impact of cultural values and situations upon literature. You will select one of the four questions. Whatever question you choose, develop a clear thesis and support your position with examples from the text. Discuss the cultural issues in the work(s). Summarize the positive and negative cultural impacts of the events described in the works. Option 1 Compare a work from one of the World War I poets (Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, or Wilfred Owen) to Winston Churchill’s “Wartime Speech.” Based on these two works, do you think attitudes in Britain changed between the time in which the poem was written and the time in which Churchill gave his speech? If so, how? What changed? Why did these changes occur? Option 2 In “Shooting and Elephant,” Orwell’s opinion about imperialism is that “when the white man turns tyrant, it is his own freedom that he destroys.” What does he mean by this statement? What was the English reason for colonizing in the first place? How does Orwell’s experience in Burma prove his opinion? Use examples from the story. Option 3 Compare and contrast the effects of imperialism upon the indigenous characters in “No Witchcraft for Sale” and in “B. Wordsworth.” Consider the countries that are described in each story. How were the characters treated similarly? How were they treated differently? To what extent were the effects of imperialism internalized by the characters? Project 3 1 ENGH 044 Option 4 In what ways does Omeros reflect modernism? Re-read the section in your textbook that discusses modernism (pages 1131–1132) and use quotations from the poem to defend your thoughts. Emphasize the cultural situations of the characters. You may do your project as an essay, a slideshow presentation (Power Point or Prezi), or a website. • If you choose the essay option, it should be 1,200 words in length. • If you do the slideshow, it should include at least 20 slides in which you address all aspects of the question you are answering. You should present a clear thesis / argument and support it with well-organized ideas. Headings should be easy to identify, and all text, including bulleted lists, should be easy to read. You may be creative in how you set up your slides, but each slide should contribute an idea to your presentation and none should appear cluttered. • If you do the website option, you should address all aspects of the question you are answering. You may be creative, but you should present a clear thesis or argument that you support, use original ideas and organization, and follow proper conventions. Text should include proper grammar, punctuation, and spelling, and images should relate to your argument, rather than being purely illustrative. Project 3 will be graded according to the following rubric. Point breakdown is: Thesis Statement: Ideas / Content: Organization: Language and Style: 10 points possible 10 points possible 10 points possible 5 points possible 10 Thesis Statement Project 3 Thesis statement is very clear and clearly addresses the posed question. 8 Thesis statement is clear and generally answers the posed question. Sentence Fluency: 5 points possible Conventions: 5 points possible Citations: 5 points possible Total points possible: 50 6 Thesis is unclear, but a main idea is generally present and on topic. 2 4 Thesis statement is unclear, and main idea is not clearly on topic. 2 Thesis statement is unclear, and main idea is off topic. 0 Thesis statement is missing and main idea is unclear. ENGH 044 Ideas/ Content Details are clear, specific, and accurately summarize the text. Support of the thesis is clear. Details are accurate and summarize the text. Support of the thesis is apparent. Details are present and give a general idea of the text. Some connections to the thesis are present. Details are vague and do not give a clear summary of the text. Support of the thesis is lacking. Details are confusing and do not summarize the text. There is almost no connection to the thesis. No details from the text. No connection to the thesis. Organization Effective order of detail with transitions connecting ideas. Welldeveloped intro, body, and conclusion and solid use of paragraphs. Strong order with some transitions. Intro, body, and conclusion are all developed and paragraphs generally used correctly. Attempts to organize with weak transitions. Intro, body, and conclusion are not fully developed, and paragraphs are attempted. Lacking organization with few to no transition. Intro, body, and conclusion are not developed or might be missing and paragraphs are incorrect. Disorganized and confusing with no apparent transition. Intro, body, and conclusion are not identifiable and paragraphs are lacking. Organization is not attempted and no transitions are apparent. Missing intro, body, or conclusion and no paragraphs are used. Project 3 3 ENGH 044 5 4 3 2 1 0 Language and Style (Word Choice/Voice) Words chosen clearly communicate meaning and thoughts. Vocabulary is accurate, natural, and appropriate. Style is unique and appropriate. Words chosen communicate meaning and thoughts. Vocabulary is sufficient for communicating ideas. Style is natural. Words chosen are general in communication of meaning and thoughts. Vocabulary, while perhaps accurate, is not clearly followed. Style is attempted and successful at times. Words may be confusing at times. Vocabulary might be overdone or too basic. Style is unnatural. Words chosen are confusing throughout. Vocabulary may be unnatural or distracting. Style is lacking originality. Words have no meaning. There is no style. Sentence Fluency Sentences are smooth and easy to read. Varied in length and structure throughout. Sentences are easy to read. Varied in length and structure at times. Sentences are sometimes awkward. Lacking in a variety of length or structure. Sentences are often difficult to read. Choppy or run together sentences are noticeable. Sentences are difficult to read. Choppy or run together sentences to the point of distraction. Sentences contain such lack of fluency that it is challenging to read for understanding. Conventions (spelling, punctuation, capitalization, grammar, including titles!) No glaring errors. Readability seems flawless. If errors are present, they do not distract the reader. Occasional errors, but not too distracting. Frequent errors affect the readability. Numerous errors are distracting throughout and make the text hard to read. So many errors it cannot be read for understanding. Project 3 4 ENGH 044 Citations and Works Cited page (as needed) Follows MLA format correctly. Inline citations and Works Cited page done correctly. Follows MLA format with few errors. Citations and Works cited page are used as needed with few errors. Follows MLA format, with some errors. Attempted citations and Works Cited page but contains errors. Does not use MLA format. Citations and Works Cited page contain many errors. Does not follow MLA style. Missing citations and Works Cited page information. No citations and no Works Cited page. Total Score out of 50 possible points: Project 3 5 ENGH 044 Essay Option Begin typing here (delete directions for the other options). Website Option Complete this table so your teacher can access your site: Name of Student Title of Speech URL link to your speech Citations for any outside sources used (in proper MLA format) Slideshow Option Upload your slideshow to the UNHS Dropbox: 1. Access the high school DropBox. To access the DropBox, use the navigation panel on your course management system (Waycool) homepage. 2. Click “Browse” to select your file. (A new “Browse” button will appear after you have selected your file. Disregard it. This feature of the DropBox is for projects in which students need to submit more than one file.) 3. Click “Begin Upload.” 4. Wait until a message appears on your screen saying “Your Upload is Complete.” This message will provide a URL to your file so it can be viewed online. 5. Copy the URL and paste it into the table on the next page of this project assignment document (scroll down). Be sure to copy your URL before you close the DropBox upload page. 6. Complete the table on the next page so your teacher can access your presentation. Project 3 6 ENGH 044 Name of Student Title of Slideshow URL link to your slideshow Citations for any outside sources used (in proper MLA format) To submit Project 3, save this project assignment document. Use the course number, your name, and the project number in your file’s title: ENGH044060_Your_Name_Here_Project3.doc Go to your course management system to upload your project file. Project 3 7 ENGH 044
Purchase answer to see full attachment
User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Explanation & Answer

please find the attached files. let me know if you need any adjustments. always a pleasure. good bye

Student 1
Name
Student id
Date
Outline
1. Introduction
a. George Orwell's piece "Shooting an Elephant" presents dominant themes of conflict and
hatred. Orwell experiences inner battles with himself as he is torn between doing what he
knows is right and what the society and his line of work expects him to do.
b. Orwell, through his essay, explains that imperialism was an evil thing to both the
suppressor and the suppressed, and power comes with a price that the suppressor has to
pay to maintain it.
2. Why British colonized Burma
a. During the imperialist era, the British colonized Burma in search of power. Burma was
occupied by Indians who owned elephants for cultivation. The British colony took away
their lands, imprisoned the rebellious Burmese people, and made them slaves.
3. Meaning of Orwell’s statement
a. Orwell states that “When the white man turns tyrant, it is his own freedom that he
destroys."
b. By this, he means that when the white man overpowered the native Indians, he lost living
in total control of himself. He lost his freedom as a free man, and from then, his deeds
were always determined by the natives.

Student 2
c. Orwell also means that when the white man started reigning in lower Burma, he became a
puppet. In the essay, Orwell shoots the elephant. However, in his heart, he did not want
to. He had asked for the rifle to protect himself.
d. However, when the crowd follows him, Orwell is forced to choose between being
deemed as a fool and weak and shooting the elephant and going against what he believes
is right.
e. The essay is filled with symbolism. The elephant is a symbolism of the Burma society,
which was once powerful like the elephant but was colonized and overpowered by the
British colonizers.
4. Conclusion
a. By stating that “When the white man turns tyrant, it is his own freedom that he destroys,”
Orwell tries to explain that imperialism was evil, and power comes with a price. With
power, resistance is inevitable.


Name

_________________________________

I.D. Number

_______________________

Project 3
Evaluation 33
ENGH 044 060 Twelfth Grade English 2
Be sure to include ALL pages of this project (including the directions and the assignment)
when you send the project to your teacher for grading. Don’t forget to put your name and I.D.
number at the top of this page!
Project 3 is worth 50 points. It is worth 12 percent of your course grade. For this project, you will
choose one option. A rubric is provided so you know how you will be graded and what is required.
Please look over the rubric as well as reading the comments it provides. Also, review the appendix
in this course for more about writing essays, thesis statements, paragraphs, MLA style, and
conventions.

Cultural Analysis
In this project, you will examine the impact of cultural values and situations upon literature. You will
select one of the four questions. Whatever question you choose, develop a clear thesis and support
your position with examples from the text. Discuss the cultural issues in the work(s). Summarize the
positive and negative cultural impacts of the events described in the works.
Option 1
Compare a work from one of the World War I poets (Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, or Wilfred
Owen) to Winston Churchill’s “Wartime Speech.” Based on these two works, do you think attitudes in
Britain changed between the time in which the poem was written and the time in which Churchill
gave his speech? If...

Related Tags