In his celebrated "Dream Argument," Descartes maintained that we
should not trust any test that purports to distinguish dreaming from
waking states. For any test you can think of, Descartes argued, you can
never know whether you actually performed the test (and so have in hand
useful test results) or whether you merely dreamed that you performed it
(and so do not have any test results -- the test never took place
because you merely dreamed that you performed it!).
Your assignment this week is to apply Descartes' argumentation to the
"pinch test," according to which if you pinch yourself hard right now
and feel a sharp stab of pain then you know that you are awake. Please
be sure that your essay addresses the following:
- What would what would Descartes conclude about the reliability of the pinch test?
- Exactly why would he conclude this?
- Do you agree with Descartes' reasoning and conclusion? Why or why not?
Please ensure that your essay addresses each component of the
assigned questions and that your answer is well-organized, uses
excellent, college-level prose, and makes judicious use of textual
evidence. Your essay should be 600-900 words long.
I will not pay any prices exceeding my budget range.