PRJ 2230 Troy University Defamation Laws Essay

PRJ 2230

Troy University


Question Description

I’m studying for my Writing class and need an explanation.

CASE STUDY – Amazon v. New York Times

In 2015, the New York Times ran a negative story about Amazon’s workplace conditions. To combat this negative coverage, Jay Carney, a former White House press secretary and Amazon’s senior vice president for corporate affairs, criticized the New York Times story and its source on Medium.com. sources from this story included anonymous sources that did not reveal their true identities because of a nondisclosure agreement with Amazon.

A major source for this story, a former Amazon employee, Bo Olsen, gave an interview with the New York Times criticizing Amazon’s workplace. In his response, Carney revealed that Olsen was under investigation for fraud during his time at Amazon. Olsen actually admitted he had attempted to defraud vendors and resigned his position because of that. This case study illustrates corporations’ willingness to use communication tactics, as opposed to legal ones, to combat negative publicity. The case study of Amazon v. NYT presents an example of the tensions between defamation and privacy laws and demonstrates how corporations use social media platforms to combat negative press attention.

For your assignment I want you suppose you work as the social media manager for the restaurant chain Best Burger. One day while scanning posts about your company, you see that someone on Twitter posted three very negative comments about Best Burger. The comments were as follows:

Tweet 1: Best Burger is the WORST restaurant EVER!!! #nevereathere

Tweet 2: Best Burger’s food tastes like cardboard. It isn’t even real food

Tweet 3: Best Burger is not worth the price. They use dog food to make their hamburgers.

Assuming that Best Burger thinks its hamburgers are great and that the do not use dog food to make them, are any of these comments subject to defamation laws? Why or why not? Write a two-page paper regarding your answer. Word count: 500-700 words

Student has agreed that all tutoring, explanations, and answers provided by the tutor will be used to help in the learning process and in accordance with Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Final Answer


Surname 1
Defamation Laws
Defamation remains a civil violation that fits apprehensively within the range of tort law.
Thus, it has continued to be rather a nebulous perception within tort. The cases of new forms of
defamation as a tort are based upon the impact of the internet and freedom of speech and
expression. In the modern world, reputations are reinforced or destroyed according to what
customers publish online (Laidlaw and Young 112-161). Indeed, most customers' reviews are
protected under the First Amendment, which permits free speech (Laidlaw and Young 112-161).
Nonetheless, a court of law can establish that a reviewer is liable for defaming a business if the
person posts incorrect factual information. Accordingly, freedom of speech typically is based on
whether an individual is expressing his or her opinion or proclaiming a fact.
All three reviewers are trying to pass information regarding their experience with Best

FelixBrato (9236)
Rice University

I was on a very tight deadline but thanks to Studypool I was able to deliver my assignment on time.

The tutor was pretty knowledgeable, efficient and polite. Great service!

I did not know how to approach this question, Studypool helped me a lot.