San Jose State University Jazz Song My Favorite Things Song Discussion

San Jose State University

Question Description

I need an explanation for this Music question to help me study.

John Coltrane is an undisputed giant of jazz. There was an evolution in his creative style-both as composer and performer-from 1957 to 1964. Yet, there is an aspect of Coltrane's performance artistry that remains distinctly identifiable throughout his career. Remarkably, his music would evolve further in the last three years of his life (1964-1967) into the realm of free jazz, some of which we will hear in this course.

Listening attentively to My Favorite Things played by John Coltrane, soprano saxophone (ss); McCoy Tyner, piano (p); Steve Davis, bass (b); and Elvin Jones, drums (d); and address the following questions:

  1. Provide counter numbers for the beginnings and ends of the solos by McCoy Tyner and John Coltrane. (The order of solos in this piece is: Coltrane (melody), Tyner, Coltrane.)
  2. Tyner plays the A section and then "vamps" with the pedal point in the bass before he begins to solo. A vamp is when one or two chords are repeated, usually with a pedal point. Coltrane also states the A section in his solo. Describe their solo styles.
  3. Listen to Tyner and Coltrane phrase or create musical lines over the chord changes. Do Tyner and Coltrane solo on the chord changes of the melody? Do you recognize the modal characteristics of these solo sections? Try to include some detail.
  4. Describe the rhythmic feel of drummer Elvin Jones and bassist Steve Davis during Coltrane's solo. Would you describe the style of these soloists as bop, hard bop, modal, elements of all or something else? Explain in detail using what you've learned from the Lessons about these particular styles.

Student has agreed that all tutoring, explanations, and answers provided by the tutor will be used to help in the learning process and in accordance with Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Final Answer

There you have it


My Favorite Things played by John Coltrane
Student’s Name:
Institution Affiliation:


Q1: Provide counter numbers for the beginnings and ends of the solos by McCoy Tyner and John
Coltrane. (The order of solos in this piece is: Coltrane (melody), Tyner, Coltrane.)
The Jazz song “My Favorite Things” could be considered a stripped-down version of the
Broadway Musical and film "The Sound of Music." The measure of the whole song appears to
be a 4/4 with it having a pretty steady beat and constant return to the melody with the use of
vamps with a form of Intro, AABA, AABA, AABC, and outro. It is hauntingly beautiful in the
bleak tonality with such a limited range of notes while also taking only the essence of the
original. Tyner’s solos are the intro and the first vamp, 0:00 - 0:17, the second of two AABA
forms with three vamps, 2:18 - 7:01. Coltrane's has two form solos, the first AABA, and the
second AABC, which is the third and final form of the song. His solo in the AABA chorus has
three vamps, 0:18 - 2:17, and his second chorus has three vamps as well, 7:02 - 12:49. Tyner
plays the piano so painstakingly bare on the chaos scale with it being an energetic performance,
but that is rigid in its creativity. This serves a stark contrast to Coltrane, who...

ProfTutorA (3148)
University of Virginia

I was on a very tight deadline but thanks to Studypool I was able to deliver my assignment on time.

The tutor was pretty knowledgeable, efficient and polite. Great service!

I did not know how to approach this question, Studypool helped me a lot.

Similar Questions
Related Tags