Critical Thinking and Problem Solving
In Week Two, you created a presentation on why linking assessments with
report cards that reflect CCSS is imperative. In this discussion, you
expand on your knowledge about CCSS and debate the idea of whether
creating high-quality assessments is necessary. Note that some educators
argue that it is not enough to just create a link between assessments
and report cards, but that assessments need to be high level and should
require students to synthesize their learning instead of only
demonstrating mastery by rote memory. Alternatively, some educators
argue that high-quality assessments cost more than lower quality
assessments (Eisner, 2001; Matthews, 2006; Pulfrey, Buch, & Butera,
2011). One possible reason for this viewpoint is that higher-level
assessments often include performance tasks and/or essays that require
teacher scoring, and thus a great deal of time is spent on evaluating
students’ work. Conversely, lower-level assessments measuring basic
knowledge through multiple-choice and true/false responses; they can be
measured using technology and take considerably less time and resources
First, choose a side from the two opposing viewpoints described above and discuss one of these two points:
- Can the American education system afford assessments for deeper learning?
- Can the American education system afford not to have such high-quality assessments?
Next, discuss if it is necessary to share assessment items, rubrics and 21st-century practices with fellow colleagues.
: Respond to at least two peers. Find one peer
who has the same argument you chose and one peer who chose the viewpoint
you did not. Debate how your viewpoint is different. If your viewpoint
is similar to that of your peers discuss the similarities. Evaluate your
peers’ responses to the use of multimedia resources with regard to
critical thinking and problem solving. Though two replies is the basic
expectation, for deeper engagement and learning, you are encouraged to
provide responses to any comments or questions others have given to you,
including the instructor. Responding to the replies given to you will
further the conversation and provide additional opportunities for you to
demonstrate your content expertise, critical thinking, and real-world
experiences with this topic.