Texts and Ideas Antiquity and The 19 Th Century Comparative Essay

User Generated

1971_

Humanities

Description

TEXTS AND IDEAS: ANTIQUITY AND THE 19TH CENTURY

For this paper you should take TWO (human) characters, each from DIFFERENT texts (e.g. Joseph and Antigone, or Agamemnon and Creon), and consider the following questions:

(a) Does the character seem to you believable – in other words, is this someone you could imagine meeting, or existing in real life? If not, what do you think is missing – what would you expect to find that is lacking here? If on the other hand the person does seem believable, what makes him/her so? Is it (for example) the situation that s/he finds him/herself in, or his/her response to that situation? Or is it something about the way s/he is described – the author’s description of his/her actions, or of his/her thoughts and feelings, for example?

(b) How do the two characters compare? In particular, are there any differences in the way they respond to the dilemmas they face? A useful exercise might be to think how they would behave if their situations were reversed. If Homer’s Hector were faced with the issue of burying his brother against the law, is there any indication what his response would be? What if Moses was deprived of something that he has reason to think should by rights be his, in the way that Achilles is? Or what would Achilles do if he received a divine command to challenge a king who was enslaving his people?

The paper should be 5-6 pages (around 2000-2200 words) long and should be DOUBLE-SPACED. I recommend that you spend about 2 pages discussing each character separately, and 1-2 pages doing the comparison at the end. This should be based on a close reading of the text, giving specific examples with page-numbers, but do not quote excerpts longer than a clause or short sentence: you should describe things in your own words. With some characters you may find you have to be very selective: that process of selection is part of the exercise. It is more important that you focus on the things that you think are the most significant than that you try to cover every point.

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Explanation & Answer

Attached.

Surname 1
Name
Institution
Instructor
Date
Antiquity and the 18th Century
Often when reading ancient texts, individuals try to resonate with the characters
presented there. Various questions may linger in the readers' minds, including whether these
would be real and fictional characters. On a more in-depth analysis of the same, there is usually
the tendency of thinking of the best ways in which the individual could change the characters to
fit into more human stature where they do not fit. This essay explores two such characters from
ancient texts. The characters are Joseph from the Bible in the book of Genesis and Agamemnon
from Achilles's Rage. The essay will detail their characterization and how they fit/ don't fit into
the human race.
Joseph was the son of Jacob and Rachel and played an essential role in the tribe of Israel.
The story of Joseph is told in Genesis 37-50. Joseph grows as the favorite of his father and is,
therefore, the subject of hate from his brothers. They then plot to sell him into slavery and lie to
the father that a wild animal attacked him. In a twist of fate, Joseph manages to become a leader
in Israel and later faces the brothers and saves them from a famine that has stricken their land.
Joseph can meet with his father before he dies, making quite an exciting story. From a personal
perspective, Joseph is someone that I would not believe meeting in real life, especially in the
present-day corrupted world. His responses to situations, especially hard ones (which are the
majority), make him an unbelievable character.

Surname 2
One of the significant reasons for this line of thought is how Joseph dreams about future
events. The book of Genesis notes that Joseph would have dreams and share them with the
brothers and the father. The first dream was, "Listen to this dream that I dreamed. ⁷There we
were, binding sheaves in the field. Suddenly my sheaf rose and stood upright; then your sheaves
gathered around it, and bowed down to my sheaf.” (Genesis 37:7). This was an occurrence that
was to happen in the future, meaning that Joseph's dreams were accurate predictions of the
future. In the present world, meeting a person whose dreams are accurate predictions is an
unlikely situation. Most people will be false prophets. The element that should be added here to
make Joseph m...

Related Tags