Business Finance
SEU The Benefits of Accrual Basis in Accounting Research Paper

Saudi electronic university

Question Description

I’m studying and need help with a Accounting question to help me learn.

-No matching ratio please.

-Word document only.

-Use size 12 Times New Roman font, double spaced.

- My topic is about the shifting towards accrual accounting in public sector in Saudi Arabia.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Assignment Question(s): Q1 Activity: A. Visit Saudi Digital Library using your student ID/ You can also search from Google and choose at least 5 research articles on accounting in which you are interested and would like to investigate. You might have observed that every article starts with an Abstract, explain in your words what is an abstract and how does it help other researchers. B. Write the title and author of each article and summarize the finding of each author in all the 5 articles and write a critical comment on them. C. Develop one Question/ Topic of your own based on all the comment you made from the summary above. 2. Research proposals includes: 1. Title, 2. Abstract, 3. Issues, 4. Objectives, 5. Literature, 6. Method, 7. Benefits. Write down a research proposal on the question developed in Q1. (1.5 Marks) 3. Data collection depends upon the choice of research method adopted like: 1. The research question, 2. Data access and 3. What the researcher wants to do. Develop at least 10 questions on the objectives you created in your proposal to collect data/ Survey. (1Mark) 4. The trade-off between reliability and construct validity has been referred to between internal/external validity. Explain them. (0.5 Marks) Administración pública re v is ta innovar journal Accrual financial reporting in the Public Sector: Is it a reality? Isabel Brusca Alijarde Universidad de Zaragoza, Spain. Departamento de Contabilidad y Finanzas. Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales. E-mail: ibrusca@unizar.es Vicente Montesinos Julve Universidad de Valencia, Spain. Departamento de Contabilidad. Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales. E-mail: Vicente.Montesinos@uv.es Información financiera de devengo en el sector público: ¿es una realidad? Resumen: La modernización de la contabilidad pública ha llevado consigo la implantación de información financiera basada en el principio de devengo. No obstante, en algunos países europeos, como por ejemplo España, el presupuesto continúa elaborándose mediante el criterio de caja o caja modificada y por consiguiente ambos sistemas coexisten. Esto puede convertirse en un problema para la implantación real del principio de devengo. Este artículo analiza las diferencias que existen en la práctica entre el resultado presupuestario y el resultado económico, con el objetivo de evidenciar si realmente existen diferencias significativas entre uno y otro y poner así de manifiesto en qué medida la contabilidad de devengo ha sido implementada de forma real. Abstract: Although modernization of governmental accounting has led to the implementation of accrual financial reporting, budgets in most continental European countries, including Spain, continue to be based on cash or modified cash methods. Consequently, cash-based and accrualbased financial information coexist. This may create problems for the full implementation of accrual financial statements. This paper analyzes the differences in practice between the results disclosed in financial and budgetary statements under both bases of accounting in order to identify to what extent accrual accounting has been implemented and to verify whether budgetary and accrualbased financial figures are significantly different. The research findings show that there is a high correlation between the current budgetary result and the economic result and, therefore, that in practice the accrual principle has not been implemented effectively. Keywords: Public sector accounting, accrual accounting, local government, financial reporting. Palabras clave: contabilidad del sector público, contabilidad de devengo, gobierno local, reportes financieros. Rapport d’accroissement financier dans le secteur public : une réalité ? Résumé : La modernisation de la comptabilité publique a mené avec elle l’implantation d’information financière basée sur le principe d’exercice. Cependant, dans certains pays européens, comme l’Espagne, par exemple, le budget continue d’être élaboré selon un critère de caisse ou de caisse modifiée et par conséquent les deux systèmes coexistent. Cela peut devenir un problème pour la mise en place réelle du principe d’exercice. Cet article analyse les différences qui existent dans la pratique entre le résultat budgétaire et le résultat économique, pour mettre en évidence s’il existe réellement des différences significatives entre l’un et l’autre et démontrer ainsi dans quelle mesure la comptabilité d’exercice a été mise en place de façon réelle. Mots-clés : Comptabilité du secteur public, comptabilité d’exercice, gouvernement local, rapport financier. Informação financeira de acréscimo no setor público: É uma realidade? Resumo: A modernização da contabilidade pública tem levado consigo a implantação de informação financeira baseada no princípio da especialização dos exercícios. No entanto, em alguns países europeus, como a Espanha, por exemplo, o orçamento continua sendo elaborado mediante o critério de caixa ou caixa modificada e, em consequência, ambos os sistemas coexistem. Isto pode virar um problema para a implantação real do princípio da especialização dos exercícios. Este artigo analisa as diferenças que existem na prática entre o resultado orçamentário e o resultado econômico, com o objetivo de evidenciar se realmente existem diferenças significativas entre um e outro e mostrar assim em que medida o regime contabilístico do acréscimo foi implementado de maneira real. Palavras-chave: Contabilidade do setor público, regime contabilístico do acréscimo, governo local, relatórios financeiros. Departamento de Contabilidad y Finanzas (At. Isabel Brusca). Facultad de Economía y Empresa. Gran Vía, 2-3a planta. 50005-Zaragoza. Correspondencia: Brusca Alijarde, I., & Montesinos Julve, V. (2014). Accrual Financial Reporting in the Public Sector: Is it a Reality? Innovar, 24(54), 107-120. Citación: Clasificación JEL: M41. RECIBIDO: Febrero 2012; APROBADO: Septiembre 2013. Introduction In recent years, most Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries have introduced important reforms into their public accounting systems following New Public Management (NPM) perspectives and principles. These reforms have a two-fold objective: To improve public service management and to increase the transparency and accountability of governments (Caperchione, 2006; Chan & Xiaoyue, 2002; Lapsley, 1999). Reforms of government accounting generally focus on implementing accrual-based information systems, conforming to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), and progressively bringing procedures in-line with the business accounting model (Hood, 1995; Lüder & Jones, 2003; OECD, 2002). Australia, New Zealand and the UK are leaders in the initiative for the convergence of the two types of accounting systems (Barton, 2009; Broadbent & Guthrie, 2008; Ryan et al., 2007). As Lapsley, Mussari and Paulsson (2009) point out, in the world of public sector accounting, the adoption of accrual accounting is self-evident and has been encouraged by the recommendations of international organizations such as the International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (IPSASB) and the OECD. However, the literature shows that there are many differences between countries (Adam, Mussari & Jones, 2011; Pina, Torres & Yetano, 2009) and that, in the implementation of accrual accounting, many problems and ambiguities arise (Arnaboldi & Lapsley, 2009). This paper 107 Administración pública focuses on one of these ambiguities: The duality of financial and budgetary accounting systems, which is a barrier to implementing accrual accounting in practice. In most continental European countries, budgets are based on cash or modified cash methods so that cash-based and accrual-based financial information coexist. This is the case, for example, in Italy, France, Portugal, Belgium and Spain. Even though a reconciliation of these two types of information is sometimes required by legal standards, the use of different recognition criteria for budgets and for financial statements can be confusing. This is why accrual statements have a secondary role in most countries where the two recognition bases coexist. Budgetary information drives the management of public entities because legal requirements refer only to this information. Guthrie (1998) points out that this duality can cause confusion for managers because they receive conflicting signals from two parallel sets of accounting figures. On the other hand, Pina et al. (2009) maintain that the dual system implemented in continental European countries may be one reason for the dissemination of accrual accounting, because it does not require the introduction of deep organizational changes and answers citizens’ democratic demands for higher responsiveness, transparency and accountability. This paper aims to analyze the extent to which there has been a real implementation of accrual accounting in a dual system, taking into account the effect on the operating statement in Spanish local governments. In Spain, accrual-based financial statements have been prepared since 1992, but budgets are still based on the modified cash basis. As a consequence of this duality, even when public managers have to prepare both types of information—and they do—for management and legal purposes, priority is given to budgetary figures and reports (Brusca & Montesinos, 2011) because the parliamentary debate is based on these figures. In fact, accrual-based financial figures are only used for accountability purposes. This study contributes to the extensive literature about implementing accrual accounting and the problems and ambiguities it causes. It aims to show, through an empirical study, that the implementation of accrual accounting has many problems in practice and that although entities always try to follow the accounting standards from a formal point of view, the implementation may not be effective. The paper offers a two-fold extension of previous accounting literature. First, it focuses on an ambiguity that has received little attention in the literature and, second, it offers an empirical perspective of the implementation and the problems that it can have in practice. It can be 108 considered as a study of the outcomes of a reform process for Spanish local governments that has already taken nearly 20 years, and complements others papers that demonstrate problems of accrual accounting in other countries, such as those of Arnaboldi and Lapsley (2009) for the UK, or Anessi-Pessina and Steccolini (2007) for Italy. The theoretical bases of this research—that is, the assumptions to be verified, the variables considered in the empirical analysis, and the design of the model which represents their functional relations—are built on the logic of the accounting model: How economic or accrual and budgetary results are determined, and the main items that constitute the differences between both results. The theoretical background of accounting behavior in public organizations, especially agency and institutional theories, has been a useful tool for explaining and analyzing the variables and circumstances that boost the adoption of accrual accounting rules and practices in public entities. Finally, in order to obtain useful research results, we have taken into consideration, for the period and variables of the study, existing previous analyses for other countries such as Italy. This enables an international comparison of the main findings of the paper. The results show that the implementation of the accrual system in local entities has been more formal than real. The problems that remain unresolved are generally recognized, such as the treatment of asset depreciation. The paper enriches the literature about the problems of accrual accounting, showing that although entities may wish to comply with the standards, managers are not necessarily interested in the information obtained through the accrual method and such information is little used in practice. The rest of the paper is organized into five sections. First we review the literature and the state of the art. We look at the use of accrual and cash bases in accounting and budgeting. What benefits and risks can the adoption of accrual imply, especially when it coexists with the cash basis? We go on to describe the situation of the Spanish local government system, referring particularly to the accrualbased statement of revenues and expenses, the statement of budget execution, and the conceptual differences between them. The fourth section provides a description of the empirical research: Objectives, sample and methodology. The results are presented in the fifth section. A final section draws some conclusions and discusses the implications for accounting practitioners and researchers. r e v. i n n ova r vo l . 2 4 , n úm . 5 4 , o ct ub r e - di ci e m b re 2014 re v i s ta innovar journal The modernization of governmental accounting reflects the common direction of reforms towards the implementation of accrual financial reporting in conformity with GAAP, using the business accounting model as a reference. The actions taken include accrual accounting reforms, in some cases accompanied by accrual budgeting, performance management systems, results-oriented and performance budgeting, and performance benchmarking. and the information can be the main vehicle for accountability to external users. In the public sector, however, the relationships between principals and agents are complex and open-ended or not explicitly defined, and are thus not easily monitored (Broadbent & Laughlin, 2003). Each individual is presumed to be motivated by self-interest and will not use the information unless it somehow contributes to their own economic wellbeing. As a consequence, agents will need reasons to use the information. From the stakeholders’ perspective, Zimmerman (1977) points out some problems that can arise in the control of the agent by the principal in this case. Because of the small probability of a voter influencing an election, each voter will incur a small expected cost. Within accrual accounting, the main objectives of financial reporting are to provide information useful for accountability and decision-making purposes. From a theoretical perspective, some theories can be used in order to explain the introduction of accrual accounting and reporting in local government. For example, according to agency theory, local government information can be used for monitoring and linking managerial action with principals (citizens), According to institutional theory, local governments may introduce accrual accounting and reporting to meet external requirements and to provide an impression of rationality and efficiency, seeking legitimacy, but will not use the system to improve internal performance (Brignall & Modell, 2000; Modell, 2001, 2004; Scott, 1987). When the process of accrual basis adoption is assessed in the light of the institutional approach, a “decoupling” can be found, as Implementation of Accrual Accounting in Governments with a Dual System Theoretical Framework re v. i n n ova r vol . 2 4, nú m . 5 4, oc tu br e-d ic i e m b r e 2 014 109 Administración pública accrual and cash-based information still co-exist in financial reporting by public entities (Archel, Husillos & Spence, 2011). As a result of this circumstance, an interesting discussion can be opened from a theoretical perspective, with the first question focused on identifying where the dominant discourse is now really located: Is it accruals, supported by academics, big firms and professional bodies, or is it cash-based reporting, supported by traditional behavior and practices? Accrual accounting is an international tendency and most governments around the world see this as an objective for their accounting systems, although there are differences in the implementation process between countries (Adam et al., 2011; Lüder & Jones, 2003; Pina et al., 2009). Lapsley et al. (2009) argue that the adoption has been self-evident because of the pressures on governments to demonstrate their effectiveness and efficiency and to discharge their responsibilities, bearing in mind that accrual financial statements can be considered as a tool to this end. The International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (IPSASB) has had an important role in these processes, especially in connection with the issue of the International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSASs) based on the accrual method. However, there are some arguments in the literature that indicate the need to be careful when extending business accounting to public sector entities, to prevent it leading to ‘perverse outcomes’ (Broadbent & Guthrie, 2008; Christiaens & Rommel 2008; Ellwood, 2003; Ellwood & Newberry 2007; Federation des Experts Comptables Européens, 2003; Guthrie, 1998; Lapsley, 2009; Lapsley et al. 2009; Newberry, 2007). Another trend even questions the advisability of introducing accrual accounting in the public sector, arguing that the benefits claimed are not being verified in practice, while the costs of shifting to accrual accounting are accepted as being substantial (Wynne, 2008). From a practical perspective, the implementation of accrual accounting systems overcomes many conflicts and ambiguities, as pointed out by Arnaboldi and Lapsley (2009). The authors highlighted the recognition and valuation of assets or the non-neutrality of accrual accounting as examples. Lapsley et al. (2009) identified similar problems relating to heritage assets, infrastructure assets, community assets, and capital maintenance and erosion. Furthermore, many authors argue that the adoption of full accrual accounting has expanded the opportunities available to governments to utilize accounting measurement discretion for the purposes of managing reported financial results (Stalebrink, 2007). For example, Vinnari and 110 Nasi (2008) consider that the heterogeneity of accrual accounting applications may lead to creative accounting solutions, especially in the public sector context, with the consequence that accounting information is not sufficiently transparent, users may be misled, and accounting does not properly fulfill its accountability functions. The literature shows that relevant questions still remain unanswered, such as the recognition and valuation of infrastructure and heritage assets (Adam et al., 2011; Christiaens, 2004; Jorge, Carvalho & Fernandes, 2007), and the usefulness of accrual financial statements has not been fully demonstrated (Arnaboldi & Lapsley, 2009; Jones & Pendlebury, 2004; Pilcher & Dean, 2009). One additional problem that persists in many European continental countries is the duality of budgetary and financial reporting systems, which can lead to a degree of ambivalence about implementing accrual accounting and also using accrual financial statements. Coordination Between Accrual and Budgetary Systems: International Experiences Australia, New Zealand and the UK use accrual accounting both for financial reporting and for budgets. In the Netherlands, local governments are also using the modified accrual basis to prepare their budgets (Van der Hock, 2005). The same situation can be found in most German local governments, where important innovations are being introduced with resource-based and output-oriented budgeting (Lüder, 2008; Ridder, Bruns & Spier, 2005), although at the moment caution prevails, especially in the Federal Government (Jones & Lüder, 2011). In Denmark, the introduction of accrual accounting in budgets was tried out in several municipalities in 2006-2007 and there is now a general process of change involving the adoption of the accrual basis in the budget. Similarly, in Finla ...
Purchase answer to see full attachment
Student has agreed that all tutoring, explanations, and answers provided by the tutor will be used to help in the learning process and in accordance with Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Final Answer

Attached.

Assignment Question(s):
Q1 Activity:
A. Visit Saudi Digital Library using your student ID/ You can also search from Google and choose at least 5
research articles on accounting in which you are interested and would like to investigate. You might have
observed that every article starts with an Abstract, explain in your words what is an abstract and how does
it help other researchers.
In most cases, an abstract is a brief summary of a research paper. a typical abstract is not too long and can
be 150 words but nor more than 300 words. An abstract is very critical because it helps researchers recall
main points in an article. An abstract also helps researches to get the essence or gist of an article or research
paper. For researchers, an abstract prepares them to follow and analyze the detailed information and
arguments in a paper.
B. Write the title and author of each article and summarize the finding of each author in all the 5 articles and
write a critical comment on them.
Brusca Alijarde, I., & Montesinos Julve, V. (2014). accrual Financial reporting in the public sector: is it a
reality?. Innovar, 24(54), 107-120.
Even though the modernization of accounting by governments has led to the adoption and implementation of
accrual financial reporting, several EUU countries the modified or cash methods for financial reporting.
Eventually, the authors report that both the accrual and cash methods could actually coexist. The coexistence
could however cause issues when it comes to the implementation of accrual financial accounting. A significant
finding in the study indicates that there is an increased correlation between the economic result and current
budgetary result. This therefore implies that the implementation of accrual financial reporting has not been
effectively implemented. The authors affirm that the implementation of accrual system is not real but more
formal in local entities. The duality of the two financial systems is a big blow to the adoption of accrual
financial reporting among many governments in the EU as it reduces the practicality of the financial reporting.
Without a doubt, it is true that the implementation of accrual accounting among local authorities is more
nominal than real. The authors however have not explained how managers can change their perspective
regarding the implementation of accrual financial systems in their financial institutions.
Md, B. R., Sk, R. M., & Mirza, R. A. (2015). Effectiveness of accrual basis accounting as compared to cash
basis accounting in financial reporting. International Journal Of Multidisciplinary Research and
Development, 2(10), 467-473.
According to the authors there are two basis of accounting namely cash basis an...

PhylisL (2291)
New York University

Anonymous
The tutor was pretty knowledgeable, efficient and polite. Great service!

Anonymous
Heard about Studypool for a while and finally tried it. Glad I did caus this was really helpful.

Anonymous
Just what I needed… fantastic!

Studypool
4.7
Trustpilot
4.5
Sitejabber
4.4
Similar Questions
Related Tags