Abstract
Issues Facing Veterans in Higher Education
by
Charles Amankwaa
MA, University of Baltimore, 2018
BS, University of Baltimore, 2013
Proposal Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of
Doctor of Public Administration
Walden University
December, 2021
Abstract
The American G.I. Forum (AGIF) contains several programs and initiatives, with
the significant program being on supporting students. The AGIF is an umbrella institution
consisting of over 1300 schools and almost half the number of student veterans recorded
over the years. AGIF can design appropriate intervention strategies for assisting in
growing the number of enrolled student veterans. Therefore, there is a need to better
understand their needs as students so that the organization can better serve them. This
study will focus on the issues facing veteran students in high education and the strategies
that AGIF can adopt to better improve their experiences while in university. The primary
theory that will guide this study is appreciative education (AE) framework as it offers
theoretical infrastructure for educational practice by advocating for an adaptable,
transformational, and interactive framework and is applicable to guide organizational
efforts and individual interactions. The study will use convenience sampling as it will
help in recruiting participants that are easily accessible and convenient. The study targets
30 veteran students that have served in the military for more than 10 years and currently
enrolled in a higher education program. The research study will use content analysis to
capture the opinions and attitudes of veteran students about the issues they face while in
higher learning institutions. The analysis of the findings will be based on the findings of
the interview’s outcomes, including the use of thematic analysis through coding and close
examination of data for the identification of broad patterns and themes.
Issues Facing Veterans in Higher Education
by
Charles Amankwaa
MA, University of Baltimore, 2018
BS, University of Baltimore, 2013
Proposal Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of
Doctor of Public Administration
Walden University
December 2021
Table of Contents
Section 1: Introduction to the Problem ................................................................................1
Introduction ....................................................................................................................1
Problem Statement .........................................................................................................3
Purpose...........................................................................................................................5
Nature of the Needs Assessment Study .........................................................................6
Significance....................................................................................................................6
Summary ........................................................................................................................7
Section 2: Conceptual Approach and Background ..............................................................9
Introduction ....................................................................................................................9
Concepts, Models, and Theories ....................................................................................9
Relevance to Public Organizations ..............................................................................12
Organization Background and Context ........................................................................14
Role of the DPA Student/Researcher ...........................................................................15
Summary ......................................................................................................................16
Section 3: Data Collection Process and Analysis ..............................................................17
Introduction ..................................................................................................................17
Setting of objectives .............................................................................................. 17
Practice-focused Question(s) .......................................................................................18
Sources of Evidence .....................................................................................................18
Evidence Generated For the Administrative Study .....................................................19
Participants ...................................................................................................................21
i
Procedures ....................................................................................................................22
Instrument used in collecting data ...............................................................................23
Data Analysis and Synthesis ........................................................................................23
Summary ......................................................................................................................25
References ..........................................................................................................................26
Appendix A: Service Order Agreement .............................................................................30
Appendix B: Set of Interview Questions ...........................................................................32
Appendix C: List of Acronyms ..........................................................................................33
ii
1
Section 1: Introduction to the Problem
Introduction
There has been an increase in the number of veterans enrolling in colleges. This
trend is likely to continue in the future, thus increasing the number of veterans pursuing
higher education (Kappell, 2017). The basis for some of the factors that contribute the
issues facing veteran students is the service status, including analyzing if the student
veterans are actively performing their duties or are reservists. The other deviation could
be a result of a lack of experience in combat conditions. Veterans that have experience in
combat are aware of the difficult life situations (Reisman, 2016). Research by Ghosh,
Santana, & Opelt (2019) showed that the functional limitations and injuries that veteran
students encounter are the primary factors that affect their participation in the college.
Student veterans are not a unique population in colleges or universities, but a sub-group
that has wide-ranging expectations, life experiences, and educational needs.
Even though veterans are likely to have maturity and broad knowledge and
understanding of various issues to the experience of learning due to their military
services, educators should be aware of the perception of the veteran student during their
transition to college. When the institution is aware of their needs, it will offer an
opportunity for the development of the most appropriate techniques aimed at
minimization of the challenges and increasing success. Addressing the issues facing
veteran students’ higher education will help in the development of a social support
system, the ability of veterans to reintegrate into civilian life, and accessibility to
healthcare services. Adjusting to life in college will help veterans to reintegrate into the
community. This is also important in enabling veterans to have a better social life that
2
includes interacting with other people in school and developing friendships. This is
important in helping the veterans’ transition well from military life to civilian life and
associate with non-veteran students.
Founded in 1948 by Hector Perez Garcia in Corpus Christi, Texas, the American
G.I. Forum (AGIF) has helped in the provision of motivation and education, postsecondary educational opportunities, and scholarship for veterans to attend college aimed
at encouraging veterans to join higher learning institutions. Since its establishment, the
Forum has offered many opportunities to veterans and soldiers interested in furthering
their educational opportunities. As one of the largest Federally Chartered Hispanic
Veterans firms in the country having Chapters in Puerto Rico and different states, the
Forum has helped in the enhancement of educational opportunities among the veteran
students. Also, it offers support to Hispanic organizations, including SER, IMAGE,
NCLR, and LULAC, among others. The Corporate Advisory Board (AGIFCAP) of the
Forum offer financial support and technical advice.
Apart from providing education opportunities to veteran students, the AGIF
focuses on the enlargement of equality of justice under the law and political and
economic opportunities for all regardless of their nationality, race, or ethnicity. Similarly,
it has helped in offering input on legislation enforcement aimed at protecting Hispanic
veteran rights and other minority groups. The other objective of AGIF is youth
motivation and leadership. Through the establishment of AGIF Youth Chapters, the
Forum has been successful in training youths in motivation and leadership values. They
aim to help with education through trade scholarships and academic to enhance better
career opportunities.
3
Problem Statement
The AGIF has played a critical role in struggling for civil rights, including
advocating veterans' benefits, reducing media distortions and stereotyping, and
desegregation of schools. The American G.I. Forum offers comprehensive services for
the service members that transition from the military to the community as a civilian.
Some of the services provided include employment services, community reintegration,
chemical dependency counseling, and job counseling, among others. It advocates for
improved services and cares for veterans to stabilize and assist them with job placement.
The primary consumers include veterans that try to regain their role in their society,
homeless veterans, those with a psychological or physical disability, creating a barrier to
employment, and recently discharged veterans. Despite the success in dealing with the
issue relating to the veteran administration's inability to provide earned benefits under the
G.I. Bill of Rights and representation and hospital care, the AGIF has struggled with
dealing with the specific issues facing veterans in the higher education.
Over the past years, various researchers have discussed the challenges veterans
face in their pursuit of higher education. Mendez et al. (2018) analyzed the experiences of
student veterans that had engaged in a transition seminar course using a single case study.
The findings indicated that there is a need to provide a purposeful transition process for
veterans who decide to pursue higher education. Additionally, previous studies have
asserted that drug abuse is a common occurrence for veteran students as compared to noveteran students (Bell, 2017). A study by Falkey (2016) used quantitative design in
studying the Post-9/11 Era transition experiences of veteran officers to increase
knowledge about the student population. He argued that despite the maturity and
4
understanding inherent to veterans as well as other broader skills gained from their
services, educators should be aware of the veteran's perceptions during their transition to
a college student.
Although the above studies have explored the differences in the experiences of
veteran students as they transition to higher education system, very little is known about
the specific issues facing veterans, make it difficult for an organization such as AGIF to
determine where it should place its resources. AGIF management states that limited
resources and inadequate research has made it challenging for the organization to achieve
this goal. American G.I. Forum (AGIF) does not receive funding or necessary resources
from state, local, or federal government to monitor its activities and operations. Over the
past years, the Forum has depended on donations to continue with its efforts of providing
the necessary assistance to veteran students in higher education.
Despite these limited resources, the management states that the Forum has been
making efforts to achieve its primary goal. One of the factors contributing to this success
is hardworking members and dedicated leaders such as Women’s and Youth chapters.
Their engagement has played a critical role in strengthening the structure of the Forum.
Inadequate resources have made it challenging for the organization to collect the input of
veteran students about their experiences while in college. Such direct input from veterans
is the primary source of the policies that AGIF can put in place to achieve its primary
goal.
It implies that the organization will require research in this area to increase its
awareness about the issues and the most effective solution to the challenges. Therefore,
this study will play a critical role in increasing the understanding of the issues that face
5
veteran students while in college. It will help to address the inadequate knowledge issue
facing the Forum. Therefore, the study will provide relevant information about the issues
facing veteran students, which will play a critical role in informing the American G.I
about future policy decisions. AGIF can design appropriate intervention strategies for
assisting in growing the number of enrolled student veterans (Rumann et al., 2011).
Research has shown that one of the common reasons as to why veterans choose to not
enroll in higher learning institutions is because they have had disappointments with the
benefits and salaries they were offered while they worked (Hannon, 2019). Also, they
may perceive that they were not meant for further education or training, which makes
them not to see the need for pursuing education after their time of service (Hannon,
2019).
Purpose
The primary purpose of this qualitative needs assessment is to provide an insight
into the issues facing veteran students to better inform AGIF regarding their experiences
so the organization may better plan services and programs to meet their unique needs.
The study will offer an insight into the most effective strategies to not only address the
challenges but also to increase the benefits that veterans gain through their educational
process. The guiding research question is, what challenges do veteran students face in
their pursuit of higher education? The findings will be essential for the American G.I.
Forum (AGIF) organization as it will enable them to learn about the challenges facing
veteran students so that they may plan services and programs to better meet their needs. It
will also help the organization to better meet the needs of veterans in the future. The
AGIF should adopt the following in addressing the challenges faced by the veterans
6
a) Develop veteran specific communities
b) Enhance smooth transitions through improving campus climate
c) Ensure that the veteran receive the traditional orientation sessions
Nature of the Needs Assessment Study
The research will carry out a qualitative needs assessment to document the
challenges facing veterans so that AGIF can formulate future programs on based on their
needs. The study will conduct qualitative interviews for at least ten veterans from three
different universities to gather information regarding their experiences in institutions of
higher learning. It will ensure that a researcher gains firsthand insight on the experiences
of veteran students in institutions of higher learning (Qu & Dumay, 2011). Also, it will
assist in gathering focused textual data that will help AGIF in addressing these challenges
in addition to uncovering substantial descriptive data of the individual experiences of
veteran officers. In the circumstance where the veteran students are not on the campus,
the researcher will request them to do a phone, Zoom, or Skype interview. A letter of the
agreement and scope of work is found in the appendix.
Significance
This research will be instrumental in improving the experiences of veteran
students while in higher education system by providing critical information to the AGIF
regarding their needs. Despite the efforts of AGIF to address the issues faced by veteran
students, they have limited information about the various challenges, hence the
difficulties to plan for future programming. It can use these findings to address the needs
and concerns of the veteran officers in higher education. AGIF can also use the results of
7
this research to advice colleges and universities on the best organizational culture that can
ensure integration of veteran students' needs into their practice. Through this study, the
forum will be able to determine the areas that are functioning effectively and those that
need adjustments to improve the experience of veterans in the university setting. Colleges
and universities can use the findings to design approaches that maximize veterans' ability
and capability. It is useful in the preparation of the learner-centered programs to increase
the skills and knowledge of veteran students. Through this research AGIF will be able to
address some of the challenges likely to affect veteran students after they complete their
tertiary education. This study will ensure that legislators understand the rights of veterans
so that they pass laws, which will ensure that the latter studies without problems. Public
administrators can use the findings from the needs assessment in planning for the future.
For instance, it will provide adequate information on programs relating to veteran affairs
and delivering services. Due to the diversity of the veteran students and broader
experiences, it is challenging to adopt a one size that fits all approach to serve them
(O'Herrin, 2011). Hence, the critical step for administrators is gauging the specific
veterans’ needs at the university before they devote resources to new initiatives. It will
help to craft successful efforts that consider enrolled student veterans’ input. Thus, it will
be crucial in designing supportive programs to improve the experience of veteran
students.
Summary
This section provided an insight into the issue the study will discuss. Higher
learning institutions will find this research useful in designing the most appropriate
policies that address the needs of veteran students. The study will be helpful in the
8
collection of data from the target population. Section two will outline the theoretical and
conceptual framework that forms the basis of the research.
9
Section 2: Conceptual Approach and Background
Introduction
Over the past years, veteran students have been experiencing various challenges
in the higher education system due to the practices and organizational culture that do not
consider the needs of this cohort of students. The primary question is about the policies
that the American G.I. Forum (AGIF) should implement to improve the experience of
veteran students in higher learning institutions to increase their population. This section
will discuss the theory and concepts outlined in the research as well as relevance to
public organizations. It will also discuss the significance of this discussion topic to public
organizations. The American G.I. Forum may use the data provided in the research to
determine the factors that affect veterans in the higher education system and strategies
aimed to adopt to improve their experience. It will also give an overview of the American
G.I. Forum by discussing its purpose and the significance of research in the achievement
of its goal. The last part will involve the discussion of the role of the DPA student in
researching on behalf of AGIF.
Concepts, Models, and Theories
This section will introduce and describe the theories that offer an insight into the
factors that ground this study. The segment will comprise concepts and their definition
and reference to all the relevant scholarly literature and the available theory applicable to
this study.
Appreciative education (AE) is a critical framework for guiding higher education
professionals' interaction with students, delivering student-centered services, and leading
10
higher education. It offers a positive and international approach to improve educational
enterprises by concentrating on individuals and organizations' potential and strengths to
achieve co-created goals. This concept is a powerful synthesis of appreciative advising,
appreciative inquiry, positive psychology, and social constructivist approaches.
Appreciative education offers a flexible framework and theoretical infrastructure for
educational practice (Bloom et al., 2013). Rather than concentrating on either
organizational or individual development, AE advocates for an adaptable,
transformational, and interactive framework and is applicable to guide organizational
efforts and individual interactions.
Studies have applied the appreciative framework to develop mission-centered
learning outcomes by embracing positive mindsets, empowering learners to take
ownership of the learning process, and leveraging students' strengths and assets. For
example, He, Hutson, & Bloom (2014) analyzed the need to engage in appreciative
education. They found greater potentials for applying the AE framework in educational
settings to offer learners a seamless educational pipeline that develops, leverages, and
recognizes their assets and strengths.
Similarly, Bloom & McClellan (2016) discussed a theory-to-practice framework,
according to the AE model for higher education administrators to adopt to foster creative
solutions to address challenges faced by higher education institutions to pursue the
desired goals. The discussion showed that using the AE model helps create an innovative
educational environment that can help address all the challenges that face higher
education.
11
Jeffery & Halcomb-Smith (2020) researched different works regarding the
concept of appreciative education and found out that veterans deserve feedback in their
learning process to ensure that they understand their progress. The strength of this study
lies in the fact that the authors inform in detail regarding the issue of appreciative
education. They elaborate on the issue of how tutors and veteran students can collaborate
to make the educational experience much better than it was in the past for both parties.
The weakness of the study is seen where it does not give leads to other documents that
could give good information regarding the concept of appreciative education. It could
have ensured that readers understand other sources that they can use to develop their
knowledge regarding the concept. The study has left enough room for more research
regarding appreciative education.
A critical component of AE framework is that, although each student is unique,
educators need to concentrate on the populations with greater needs than others. It is
critical to view learners as individuals as opposed to representatives of a particular group.
However, educators should also be aware that students have a likelihood of belonging to
groups that may put them in social or educational disadvantage. Therefore, they may
require differentiated attention from the teachers. While it might be challenging to find
students with identical needs, being knowledgeable of the needs of veteran students in
education is vital in increasing understanding of the issues that they face and develop
strategies to improve their experiences.
Veterans represent a unique population because of their age and experiences.
Currently, veterans result in multiple challenges to higher education, including social
12
isolation, inability to continue with education, and increased relocation. Financial issues
continue to be the most challenging factor amongst this population. Despite joining
college being a positive transition, this experience may be hard and, in some instances,
overwhelming. Returning veterans bring higher maturity and broader knowledge to
global issues due to their military expertise, educators should show them support during
this period. Increasing the awareness of this population's needs from the onset allows the
development of the most appropriate techniques for minimization of the attrition and
enhancement of success chances. The students should start with an assessment of the
commitment of the institution to provide a military-friendly environment through the
creation of on-campus units such as Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC).
Relevance to Public Organizations
The signing of the G.I. Bill of Rights into law by President Franklin Roosevelt on
June 22, 1944, resulted in the return of veterans into universities and colleges in the
country (Murray, 2008). One of the common challenges facing veteran students is their
inability to reintegrate into civilian life and lack of preparation of the schools to
accommodate the student influx (Borsariet al., 2017). It led to the emergence of more
issues for veterans, including the absence of transitional assistance as well as increased
shortages in housing, as Murray (2008) asserts. The American G.I. Forum of the United
States (AGIF) is an organization that addresses the needs and concerns of American
military veterans in higher education. Since its official incorporation in 1948, AGIF has
been at the forefront in the provision of support, resources, and programs to the
13
continuously changing local student veteran organization networks (Rumann, Rivera, &
Hernandez, 2011).
According to Hannon (2019), the number of veterans in the United States
amounts to over eighteen million. Out of these eighteen million, the number of student
veterans in the year 2013 was a little over one million, as indicated by those veterans who
have utilized their GI benefits ("Who Are Today's Student Veterans?" n.d.). Since 2013,
the statistics were estimated to increase by around twenty percent, which amounts to
approximately 1.25 million veterans ("Who Are Today's Student Veterans?" n.d.). While
there are aged veterans who may not have an interest in pursuing higher education, the
numbers who can benefit from higher education are still high, as Hannon (2019) asserts,
which prompted this research. Rumann et al. (2011) explain that the American GI Forum
of the United States is an umbrella organization for student veterans' groups, which
advocate improvements in veteran educational benefits. As an umbrella organization,
AGIF is an association of institutions that work together to coordinate the scholarly
activities of veterans. Given the collective nature of AGIF, it will help in providing data
on the veterans that are pursuing higher education. The information will be useful in the
research in the determination of the strategies to increase the population of student
veterans. The needs assessment is critical in helping organizations such as AGIF to work
with institutions of higher education to determine the gaps that hinder them from
realizing the desired goal of providing quality services to all students. Being aware of
what is currently working effectively and areas that require improvements is vital in
progressing towards achieving such goals and making universities successful.
14
Different research could inform veterans regarding how they can navigate their
application processes in institutions of higher learning. They can be given information,
which could be crucial in identifying institutions with higher chances of employment to
ensure that their college education becomes as meaningful as possible. G.Is must be
informed to ensure that they plan their college stay long before they are able to join
institutions. It could be very easy for them to plan their college stay if they set their
priorities early enough and consequently, they would also have a good experience in their
institution of choice (Kappell, 2017). Planning ought to be the best part of a G.I’s
ambition of joining a good college in the United States.
On the other hand, G.Is must plan carefully the courses they intend to take in
college. They could even decide whether they would like to undertake apprenticeship or
another course. It is advisable for the G.Is interested in joining college to consult the
department of labor using the apprenticeship finder (Kappell, 2017). In such platforms,
they could be lucky to find courses that offer favorable costs and can offer the best value
possible. In some instances, the G.Is could come across courses that offer free training to
any interested veteran.
Organization Background and Context
AGIF is an association of institutions that work together to coordinate the
educational activities of veterans. Since its official incorporation in 2008, AGIF has been
at the forefront in the provision of support, resources, and programs to the continuously
changing local student veteran organization networks (Rumann et al., 2011). As an
umbrella organization, AGIF supports over one thousand three hundred schools, which
15
justifies the relevance of the study. The mission of the organization is "to establish and
maintain a comprehensive community service agency with a diversified funding source
that will serve the needs of veterans, their families, and other needy individuals of the
community."
This research will help AGIF in the achievement of its motto of "Education is Our
Freedom and Freedom should be Everybody's Business" by providing information about
the issues facing veteran students. The initial concern of AGIF is ending segregation in
schools to offer quality education to veteran students. The objective of AGIF was to bring
the concerns of this population to mainstream politicians’ attention. Achieving this goal
depends on the ability of the forum to have adequate information about the issues faced
by veteran students in higher education, which is the primary purpose of this study. Thus,
this study is necessary to inform AGIF to implement the necessary strategies that can
help improve the experiences of veteran students in universities by addressing some of
the issues they face. It will help the organization to realize its goal of establishing and
maintaining comprehensive community service that aims at serving the needs of veteran
students.
Role of the DPA Student/Researcher
I will conduct the research on behalf of the American G.I. Forum (AGIF)
organization. In the study project, I will be the researcher; hence I will focus on the
selected target population and analyzing the collected data. Despite the focus of AGIF of
different educational issues that affect veteran students, there is still low enrollment of
veterans in top-performing colleges and universities in the country. This factor prompted
me to analyze some of the issues facing veteran students in high education. The good
16
results of the study can justify the validity of the strategies utilized by the research. There
is the likelihood of confirmation bias due to the interpretation of the data to support the
identified hypothesis. Also, I may omit some of the data that do not align with the
hypothesis.
Summary
It is evident that the study will use appreciative education (AE) framework as the
primary theory. Since there is a need to provide a purposeful transition process for
veterans who decide to pursue higher education, the above discussion has shown different
strategies that AGIF can adopt to improve their experience while in universities. Section
three will outline the methodology used by the researcher as well as the participants and
analysis and synthesis.
17
Section 3: Data Collection Process and Analysis
Introduction
The study will analyze some of the issues that face veteran students in the higher
education system to better inform AGIF regarding their experiences so the organization
may better plan services and programs to meet their unique needs. In addition to the
challenges veterans face during the transition from military to civilian life, adapting to
college life may also be a challenge (Kappell, 2017). Due to the struggles that veterans
experienced in high school, it may be hard for them to fit into the education system.
Communicating and collaborating with other students across the institution is sometimes
a struggle for veteran students. Therefore, universities and colleges that provide
educational programs to this population with unique characteristics should ensure they
implement appropriate policies that support them in adapting to college life. The third
section will discuss the research methodology, including the design, target population,
and synthesis of data. Additionally, it will examine the sources of evidence and published
outcomes and research. It will also provide an insight into the archival and operational
data as well as evidence generated from the needs assessment. It includes the following
steps; Setting objectives, selecting the audience, collecting data, selecting audience
sample, picking an instrument and then analyzing the data
Setting of objectives
a) To examine issues facing veteran students
b) To understand the most effective strategies to use in addressing the veteran
student issues
18
Practice-focused Question(s)
What are the most significant issues facing veteran students in their transition to higher
education system?
What strategies can help to improve the experience of veteran students in higher
education setting?
The researcher will conduct the study on behalf of AGIF to provide an insight into the
issues that face this population and the most appropriate strategies that can help in
addressing them to make their learning environment effective.
Sources of Evidence
Since AGIF offers different services to veteran students, it is challenging to
determine with certainty challenges that hold back veteran students from achieving their
goals. Thus, conducting a needs assessment is crucial as it will help the organization
determine the gaps that prevent veteran students from realizing the desired goals.
According to Norman et al. (2015), such gaps are evident in skills, practices, or
knowledge. Determining what is working successfully and what the organization needs to
change is vital to effective progression towards the AGIF mission and making the
organization successful. Needs assessment will help address the relevant concerns from
all firm levels to reach a plan with specific action for improvement. The effectiveness of
any plan and action depends on up-to-date and accurate information on veteran students'
needs. A needs assessment is vital in framing both problems and opportunities veteran
students face and building the necessary relationship to help deal with the identified
challenges (Garira, 2020).
19
It will offer the basis for action and planning to improve veteran students'
experiences, performance, and learning in higher education institutions by aligning
resources and strategy, setting goals for future action, and providing justifications,
insights, or data for decision-making (McCawley, 2009). The basic premise for AGIF is
to serve the veterans by addressing their needs and concerns while in universities or
colleges. The best way to fulfill this goal is by determining the needs of this population.
Therefore, conducting a needs assessment is one of the best ways to know the issues that
face veteran students and design effective intervention approaches to improve their
experiences. Another study by Nugraha et al. (2018) showed that the primary aim for
conducting a needs assessment is gathering accurate information representative of the
group under study. Therefore, it is necessary for AGIF to perform a needs assessment
before it takes any action. It is also useful in determining the current situation and
identifying issues for action while establishing the necessary basis for crucial planning.
Conducting a needs assessment is among the most critical tool for involving the veteran
students in developing goals and solving their problems (Gupta, 2011). The use of a
needs assessment will be the best way to engage veteran students and contribute to the
outcome.
Evidence Generated For the Administrative Study
Research shows that veteran students encounter the logistic challenges of
transitioning from the military to higher education (Borsari et al., 2017). Since many
veteran students enlist in the military as emerging adults and work under the structured
military environment most of the years, they lack the desired skills to navigate the
20
available services outside the military setting context. Most veteran students are unaware
of their eligibility for various helpful services, including Veteran Benefits Administration
and community programs. Despite the ability to access these services, they struggle with
effective coordination and fully utilize the different programs (Elliott, Gonzalez, &
Larsen, 2011). For instance, it is challenging to manage finances related to education.
While the educational benefits help in covering tuition, it does not include different fees.
Additionally, veteran students must incur out of pocket tuition and other benefits unless
there are correct processing and filing of the necessary paperwork. The process may take
an extended period, which places veteran students under financial distress.
The other issue relates to academic credit. Although veteran students are likely to
complete their applied training and academic coursework throughout the military service,
some institutions do not award credit for military training. Furthermore, despite veteran
students overcoming such challenges and other barriers hindering them from enrolling in
college like admission testing, benefit eligibility, and applications, retaining them in
schools is challenging (Kirchner, 2015). Radford (2009) showed that more than 40% of
part-time learners and 15% of full-time learners dropped out of colleges within the first
academic year after enrolment. Regardless of this population's academic engagement
characteristics, veteran status has a negative association with GPA. Some of the
contributing factors include increased demand on their time and attention, the likelihood
of being married and having children, and working full-time. Such competing
commitments can affect their academic performance and degree completion. Also,
veteran students experience challenges in adapting to the civilian world from their
21
hierarchical military environment. It is evident in managing time and responsibilities and
unwillingness to ask for assistance.
The study will use in-depth interviews with student veterans to obtain data for the
AGIF. It will be useful in providing primary information on the topic under investigation.
This data collection method is appropriate as it will facilitate open-ended responses from
the target population for in-depth knowledge. The primary informants from the higher
institutions regarding issues facing veteran students are the people with firsthand
information and who understand the primary issue under investigation due to their
experience with the system. Therefore, an in-depth qualitative interview allows them to
discuss the problem they encounter throughout their study in higher education institutes.
By establishing rapport and making them feel comfortable, the researcher will be able to
generate insightful responses on sensitive questions.
Participants
The participants in this study will include veteran students that are currently
studying in higher education institutions either through on-campus or online platforms.
The study will use convenience sampling (described below) as it will help in recruiting
participants that are easily accessible and convenient. The population is relevant in
discussing the topic as it will provide challenges that students face virtually and
physically. The study targets 30 veteran students. All the participants should have served
in the military for more than 10 years. Also, they should have enrolled in higher
education programs, whether online or on-campus. The study will also focus on veteran
students from different age groups. The researcher will not offer any rewards to convince
22
the target population to participate in the study. The projection is that the data collection
will take two weeks.
Procedures
The American G.I. Forum (AGIF) offered an approval letter to conduct the
research and acknowledged the importance of the selected topic in the development of
their strategy and increasing their knowledge so they may better serve their veterans. The
organization was also willing to commit resources as well as continuous feedback, and
the resources include relevant veteran information that may be helpful in this study.
Recruitment of potential participants to the research will include various phases such as
identification, approaching, and obtaining the target population’s consent to engage in the
research. The American G.I. Forum will help in identifying the participants since they
have records of the veterans who have enrolled for higher education located in various
regions across the state. The researcher will also depend on the deans of students and
student leaders for identification and approaching potential participation with the help of
the AGIF.
This type of non-probability sampling approach will depend on the collected data
from the veteran students that are conveniently available to participate in the research. It
will include getting participants from different higher learning institutions in the region.
There will be no inclusion criteria identified before selecting the participants. The
researcher will invite all the veteran students to participate in the study. Ethical protection
of the participants will include assuring the participants the data collected will be
confidential, and the researcher will not disclose personal data. Also, it will involve
23
preserving the anonymity of the participants and giving them a chance to participate
voluntarily without coercing them.
Ensuring reliability in this qualitative research will include examining the
trustworthiness of the respondents. In a qualitative research, the goal is to ensure
engagement in a study that aims at probing for deeper understanding than examining the
surface features. The adopted approach to test the study’s reliability and validity will
depend on research criterion.
Instrument used in collecting data
A set of interview questions were developed to help explore the problem
statement of the study. Only questions relevant to the research questions were developed.
This study identified 8 questions. However, the draft interview questions will be
reviewed by AGIF organization before beginning the study. These questions are available
in the Appendix section of this study.
Data Analysis and Synthesis
The research study will use content analysis to capture the opinions and attitudes
of veteran students about the issues they face while in higher learning institutions. The
research will analyze the findings based on the observations made and the outcomes of
the interview. It will include the use of thematic analysis through coding and close
examination of data for the identification of broad patterns and themes.
The study uses reflexive thematic analysis in analyzing the data collected from the
qualitative interview of each veteran student. Despite the various similarities between
qualitative content analysis and reflexive thematic analysis such as searching themes and
patterns and cutting across data, the primary difference is in the opportunity for data
24
quantification. It implies that content analysis uses descriptive approach to code and
interpret data while thematic analysis offers a purely qualitative and detailed data account
(Vaismoradi, Turunen, & Bondas, 2013).This type of data analysis identifies, interprets,
and categorizes themes (patterns of the meaning) within a qualitative dataset (Braun et
al., 2019). This concept of analysis was proposed by Braun and Clarke. Reflexive
thematic analysis fits research questions associated with how people perceive things, their
experiences, and their views (Bell, 2017). Veteran students encounter different challenges
in the institutions of higher learning that make them shy-off enrolling in advanced
learning (Babin, 2019).
The study will follow the 6 steps of conducting reflective thematic analysis as proposed
by Braun and Clarke (2018);
1) Familiarize with the data; - this is the first step of reflexive thematic analysis. The
researcher reads and re-reads the contents of the findings to understand.
2) The coding process; - This is the stage of formulating and coming up with
succinct labels (codes). These succinct labels play an integral role in establishing
words or phrases that are used in answering the statement of the problem. In this
research work, the identified codes included, "drug abuse", "lack of friends",
"mental health", "depression", "isolation," and "lack of proper advice". These
were the codes used in establishing the problems faced by veteran students in the
institutions of higher learning.
3) Formulation and identification of themes; - In this stage, themes are developed
from the identified codes.
25
4) Review and revision of themes; - in this stage, themes are analyzed to establish
their relevance in responding to the problem statement. Additionally, in this
phase, themes are re-grouped into smaller groups (sub-themes). This is also the
stage of eliminating irrelevant themes.
5) The definition and naming of themes; - this is the stage of establishing the main
idea or focus behind each theme.
6) Writing up; - this is the last phase of reflexive thematic analysis. At this point, the
extracts of data and analytical narratives are integrated.
Summary
The section has discussed the different methods the research will use in collecting
and analyzing data. This section has also identified the set of interview questions, the
codes developed, and the themes identified. The following section will discuss the
evaluation and recommendations.
26
References
Babin, J. (2019). An exploration of the perceptions and experiences of veterans
transitioning to higher education (Doctoral dissertation, Northeastern University
Boston).
Bell, B. (2017). In and Out: Veterans in Transition and Higher Education. Strategic
Enrollment Management Quarterly, 5(3), 128-134.
Bloom, J. L., Hutson, B. L., He, Y., & Konkle, E. (2013). Appreciative education. New
Directions for Student Services, 143(2013), 5-18.
Bloom, J. L., & McClellan, J. L. (2016). Appreciative administration: applying the
appreciative education framework to leadership practices in higher
education. Journal of Higher Education Management, 31(1), 195-210.
Borsari, B., Yurasek, A., Miller, M. B., Murphy, J. G., McDevitt-Murphy, M. E.,
Martens, M. P., & Carey, K. B. (2017). Student service members/veterans on
campus: Challenges for reintegration. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,
87(2), 166.
Braun, V., Clarke, V., Hayfield, N., & Terry, G. (2019). Thematic analysis. Handbook of
research methods in health social sciences, 843-860.
Falkey, M. E. (2016). An Emerging Population: Student Veterans in Higher Education in
the 21st Century. Journal of Academic Administration in Higher Education,
12(1), 27-39.
Garira, E. (2020). Needs assessment for the development of educational interventions to
improve quality of education: A case of Zimbabwean primary schools. Social
Sciences & Humanities Open, 2(1), 100020.
27
Ghosh, A., Santana, M. C., & Opelt, B. (2019). Veterans’ Reintegration into Higher
Education: A Scoping Review and Recommendations. Journal of Student Affairs
Research and Practice, 1-17 Volume 5.
Griffin, K. A., & Gilbert, C. K. (2015). Better transitions for troops: An application of
Schlossberg's transition framework to analyses of barriers and institutional
support structures for student veterans. The Journal of Higher Education, 86(1),
71-97.
Gupta, K. (2011). A practical guide to needs assessment. John Wiley & Sons.
Hannon, G. M. (2019). Post-traumatic stress and American veterans: a historical and
war literature analysis is leading to art as potential therapy (Doctoral
dissertation, Rutgers University-Camden Graduate School).
He, Y., Hutson, B. L., & Bloom, J. L. (2014). A call for action to engage in appreciative
education. Journal of Appreciative Education, 2(1), 1-9.
Johnson, R. B., & Christensen, L. (2019). Educational research: Quantitative,
qualitative, and mixed approaches. SAGE Publications, Incorporated.
Kappell, J. (2017). Student veterans’ participation in high-impact practices: Veterans’
experiences at three institutions of higher education in Southeastern North
Carolina. Journal of Veterans Studies, 2(1), 29-49.
Kirchner, M. J. (2015). Supporting student veteran transition to college and academic
success. Adult Learning, 26(3), 116-123.
McCawley, P. F. (2009). Methods for conducting an educational needs
assessment. University of Idaho, 23, 6-14.
28
Mendez, S., Witkowsky, P., Morris, P., Brosseau, J., & Nicholson, H. (2018). Student
Veteran Experiences in a Transition Seminar Course: Exploring the Thriving
Transition Cycle. Journal of Veterans Studies, 3(2), 1-18.
Murray, M. (2008). When war is work: The GI Bill, citizenship, and the civic
generation. California Law Review, 96, 967.
Norman, S. B., Rosen, J., Himmerich, S., Myers, U. S., Davis, B., Browne, K. C., &
Piland, N. (2015). Student Veteran perceptions of facilitators and barriers to
achieving academic goals. Journal of Rehabilitation Research &
Development, 52(6).
Nugraha, S. T., Suwandi, S., Nurkamto, J., & Saddhono, K. (2018). The Importance of
Needs Assessment for the Implementation of E-learning in a Language
program. KnE Social Sciences, 254-260.
O'Herrin, E. (2011). Enhancing veteran success in higher education. Peer Review, 13(1),
15.
Radford, A. W. (2009). Military service members and veterans in higher education: What
the new GI Bill may mean for postsecondary institutions. American Council on
Education.
Reisman, M. (2016). PTSD treatment for veterans: What’s working, what’s new, and
what’s next. Pharmacy and Therapeutics, 41(10), 623.
Rumann, C., Rivera, M., & Hernandez, I. (2011). Student veterans and community
colleges.New Directions for Community Colleges, 2011(155), 51-58.
Schiavone, V., & Gentry, D. (2014). Veteran-students in transition at a Midwestern
university. The Journal of Continuing Higher Education, 62(1), 29-38.
29
Vaismoradi, M., Turunen, H., & Bondas, T. (2013). Content analysis and thematic
analysis: Implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study. Nursing &
health sciences, 15(3), 398-405.
Who are Today’s Student Veterans? (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.mentalhealth.va.gov/studentveteran/studentvets.asp
Yilmaz, K. (2008). Constructivism: Its theoretical underpinnings, variations, and
implications for classroom instruction. Educational horizons, 86(3), 161-172.
30
Appendix A: Service Order Agreement
Project Proposal
This Project Proposal has been drafted by Charles Amankwaa for the American G.I. Forum (AGIF) and is
dated 8th January 8, 2021.
Scope of Work
Work Phase
Estimated Time Required
interactions:
The researcher will discuss with the administration about the
challenges facing AGIF and how inadequate data about issues
facing veteran students prevents the organization from achieving
its mission. It will include interacting with the management to
design interview questions that will help to address the needs of
this population.
1 week
Outcomes/Deliverables:
This study aims to discuss the issues facing veteran students in the
higher education system to help the organization determine the
strategies that AGIF can implement to improve the experiences of
veteran education in the universities. The research will collaborate
with the organization to help them develop strategies that that will
ensure they achieve the goal of improving the experiences of
veteran students in higher education institutions. It will include
collecting data on behalf of the organization and presenting the
findings.
2 months
Additional Services Provided if Requested:
The researcher will explain to AGIF the outcomes of
the study when requested and offer an insight into the
implications of the research findings. Similarly, the
other additional services include advising the
organizations on the areas and recommendations to
prioritize to improve veteran student experience in
higher education institutions.
4 months
Total
Services Summary
Discussing the challenges facing AGIF with the administrators to
determine the areas that require focus to improve experience of
veteran students.
Conducting research and collecting the necessary information
Data analysis and presentation
7 months
Estimated Length of
Engagement
1 week
3 months
1 month
31
Sharing the research outcomes with AGIF management upon
request
2 months
This Project Proposal has been approved by Lawrence G. Romo, National Commander.
32
Appendix B: Draft Set of Interview Questions
1. The transition from military life to civilian life is associated with many challenges.
What are the different ways of coping with the transition from military life to
college life? What challenges have you faced transitioning from military life to
being a student?
2. Institutions of higher learning that serve or wish to admit veteran students have
support programs and policies in place to make sure your needs are adequately met.
What are some of such programs or policies in this institution?
3. Have you ever considered leaving prior to the completion of your program? If so,
what would you say leads to your thinking about it?
4. Inadequate or total lack of basic military knowledge on some professors has proven
to be a challenge to understanding the needs of students with military knowledge.
Describe your professors.
5. What is your general take on the drug abuse among the veteran students?
6. Do you find any age variation between the veteran students’ age groups? How do
you think the age variations affect you?
7. In your opinion, what should the institution do to better the university experience of
most of the veteran students?
8. What advice can you give to a veteran who wishes to join the university?
33
Appendix C: List of Acronyms
AGIF
American G.I. Forum
DPA
Doctor of Public Administration
WUL
Walden University Library
IDP
International Directory of Philosophy
ERIC
Educational Resource Information Center
Purchase answer to see full
attachment