Memo to CIO on Success Criteria for Enterprise System Implementation
and Enterprise Architecture
Purpose of this Assignment
This assignment gives you the opportunity to demonstrate your ability to research,
evaluate, and explain enterprise systems, and to communicate effectively at the executive
level. This assignment specifically addresses the following course outcomes:
•
•
•
•
analyze and examine how enterprise architecture and enterprise systems influence,
support, and enable an organization's ability to contribute to strategic decision
making and to respond and adapt to the business environment
analyze enterprise system solutions to make recommendations based on benefits,
limitations, and best fit within the enterprise environment
analyze and explain the elements of a successful plan for implementing enterprise
solutions, addressing structure, processes, culture, and other considerations
analyze success criteria for higher application to enterprise architecture
Assignment
Your instructor has assigned each group one of several types of enterprise systems (SCM)
to research and prepare a paper and an executive-level informational presentation. In
Group Project 1, your team prepared a 2-3 page paper summarizing the case studies,
evaluating the success of the implementations, and identifying lessons learned. For this
assignment, you are to work independently and write a 1–3-page memo (not including
references page) to the CIO that identifies more than eight success criteria for
implementation of enterprise systems, for the category of enterprise systems assigned to
your group (ERP, SCM, CRM, etc.). (NOTE: More than eight success criteria are
required to receive all possible points; see Grading Rubric below.)
1. Each of these success criteria should be briefly explained and then related to how
they would be applied during an implementation of the assigned category of
enterprise systems within the CIO’s organization.
2. Discuss how each of the success criteria relates, on a larger scale, to satisfying the
enterprise architecture. Some areas to consider include the structure of the
organization and its processes and culture; other aspects of a proposed
implementation relate to the phases of the system development life cycle (needs
analysis, design, development, implementation, maintenance).
3. The case studies your group is using may be a good source of ideas. The criteria you
identify must be applicable to enterprise systems (in the category assigned to your
group which is SCM) and should come from your research.
Group Case Study Link:
UPS Link
https://www.supplychain247.com/article/ups_logistics_a_masterpiece_of_streamline
d_supply_chain_management/green
Coca Cola Link
https://www.allthingssupplychain.com/amazing-supply-chain-of-coca-cola/
03/15/2019
Important: Often students write this memo from the perspective of what it looks like to
have a successful implementation of ES/EA. Instead, the focus should be on the criteria that
will help you be successful! There is a difference here. For example, cost savings is the
result but not necessarily the success criteria leading up to it. Now you could contribute cost
savings to the fact that you had executive buy-in with sustained sponsorship (this could be
an example) or other criteria that includes re-engineering of business processes as
contributors. Please orient this memo such that you look at success criteria as the "drivers"
for a good implementation. Also, please remember to put this into a memo format that
looks professional. Please remember that the CIO has limited time and you should get to
the key points quickly. Please refer to the grading rubric and carefully follow the
assignment instructions!
You are to use a Microsoft Word memo template. The use of at least three external
scholarly resources (in addition to your case studies and other class materials) is
required. (NOTE: More than three external resources are required to receive all possible
points; see Grading Rubric below.) You should use scholarly journals (rather than
Wikipedia and authorless website postings). If you need assistance with determining what a
scholarly journal is, the UMUC library is a very good source of information, accessed via the
following link: http://www.umuc.edu/library/libhow/articles.cfm.
Remember to correctly cite and reference all sources. Since you are writing a memo, you
should use in-text citations and list the references on a separate page at the end.
Note: The filename of your paper should include your last name. An example would be:
Smith_Memo.doc.
Grading Rubric
Your work will be graded according to the rubric below.
Criteria
90-100%
Far Above
Standards
80-89%
Above
Standards
70-79%
Meets
Standards
60-69%
Below
Standards
< 60%
Well Below
Standards
Possible
Points
5 Points
4 Points
3.5 Points
3 Points
0-2 Points
5
There is a clearly
written
introduction to
the memo,
stating the
purpose, using
effective writing.
The introduction
adequately sets
the stage for the
memo.
The
introduction
does not
adequately set
the stage for
the memo.
No
introduction is
provided or
little effort is
shown.
18-20 Points
16-17 Points
12-13 Points
0-11 Points
More than 7
criteria for
successful
More than 7
criteria for
successful
At least 7 criteria
for successful
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
Fewer than 7
criteria for
successful
Few or no
success
criteria
There is an
effective
introduction to
Introduction
the memo,
stating the
purpose, using
sophisticated
writing.
Criteria
03/15/2019
20
Criteria
Application
of Criteria
90-100%
Far Above
Standards
80-89%
Above
Standards
70-79%
Meets
Standards
60-69%
Below
Standards
< 60%
Well Below
Standards
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
category
assigned) are
identified. Each of
the criteria is
thoroughly
explained and
each is very
clearly applicable
to enterprise
system
implementation
success. Includes
a thoughtful
explanation on
how the success
criteria relates to
enterprise
architecture.
Demonstrates a
sophisticated
understanding of
course concepts,
analysis, critical
thinking and
synthesis.
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
category
assigned) are
identified. Each
of the criteria is
clearly explained
and each is
applicable to
enterprise
system
implementation
success.
Includes a good
explanation on
how the success
criteria relates to
enterprise
architecture.
Demonstrates a
good
understanding of
course concepts,
analysis, critical
thinking and
synthesis.
category
assigned) are
identified,
explained, and
are applicable to
enterprise
system
implementation
success, and
may
demonstrate an
adequate
understanding of
course concepts,
analysis, and
critical thinking.
Some discussion
on how the
success criteria
relates to
enterprise
architecture.
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
category
assigned) are
identified. Some
of the criteria
may not be
clearly
explained,
and/or may not
be applicable to
enterprise
system
implementation
success, and/or
may not
demonstrate an
adequate
understanding
of course
concepts,
analysis, and
critical thinking.
Little to no
mention of how
this success
criteria relates
to enterprise
architecture.
applicable to
enterprise
system and
enterprise
architecture
implementation are
identified and
explained, or
are not
relevant.
45-50 Points
40-44 Points
35-39 Points
30-34 Points
0-29 Points
The application in
a successful
implementation
of enterprise
systems is fully
and clearly
described for
more than 7
criteria. Each of
the criteria is
appropriately
related to
implementation
of enterprise
The application
in a successful
implementation
of enterprise
systems is
clearly described
for more than 7
criteria. Each of
the criteria is
appropriately
related to
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
The application
in a successful
implementation
of enterprise
systems is
described for at
least 7 criteria.
The explanations
relate the criteria
to
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
category
The application
in a successful
implementation
of enterprise
systems may be
only partially
described
and/or fewer
than 7 criteria
may be
discussed. The
criteria may not
be appropriately
related to
The
explanations
for application
of the criteria
do not relate
to successful
implementation of
enterprise
systems, or
are missing;
or too few
criteria are
included.
03/15/2019
Possible
Points
50
Criteria
External
Research
Memo
Format
90-100%
Far Above
Standards
80-89%
Above
Standards
70-79%
Meets
Standards
60-69%
Below
Standards
systems (in the
category
assigned) and to
satisfying the
enterprise
architecture; and
demonstrates
sophisticated
incorporation of
course concepts
and research,
analysis, critical
thinking and
synthesis.
category
assigned) and to
satisfying the
enterprise
architecture; and
demonstrates
effective
incorporation of
course concepts
and research,
analysis, critical
thinking and
synthesis.
assigned) and
satisfying the
enterprise
architecture, and
demonstrate
adequate
incorporation of
course concepts
and research,
analysis, and
critical thinking.
implementation
of enterprise
systems (in the
category
assigned) and
satisfying the
enterprise
architecture,
and/or may not
demonstrate
adequate
incorporation of
course concepts
and research,
analysis, and
critical thinking.
14-15 Points
12-13 Points
11 Points
More than three
scholarly sources
other than the
class resources
are incorporated
and used
effectively,
contextualized,
appropriately
researched and
supported, and
synthesized with
original
arguments.
Sources used are
credible, relevant,
and timely.
Proper APA style
is used for
citations and
references.
More than three
scholarly sources
other than the
class resources
are incorporated
and used
effectively,
appropriately
researched and
supported, and
support original
arguments.
Sources used are
credible,
relevant, and
timely. Proper
APA style is used
for citations and
references.
9-10 Points
8 Points
Memo reflects
effective
03/15/2019
< 60%
Well Below
Standards
Possible
Points
10 Points
0-9 Points
15
Three scholarly
sources other
than the class
resources are
properly
incorporated and
used. Uses APA
format for
references and
citations.
Three or fewer
sources other
than the class
resources may
be used; may
not be scholarly
sources; may
not be properly
incorporated or
used to support
arguments;
may rely too
heavily on the
reporting of
external
sources, and/or
are not
effective or
appropriate;
and/or are not
credible,
relevant, or
timely. May not
use APA format.
No external
research is
incorporated
or reference
listed is not
cited within
text.
7 Points
6 Points
0-5 Points
10
Criteria
90-100%
Far Above
Standards
80-89%
Above
Standards
70-79%
Meets
Standards
60-69%
Below
Standards
< 60%
Well Below
Standards
Memo reflects
effective
organization and
sophisticated
writing; correct
structure,
grammar, and
spelling;
presented in a
professional
format using
Word memo
template.
organization; has
few errors in
sentence
structure,
grammar, and
spelling;
presented in a
professional
format using
Word memo
template.
Memo has some
organization;
may have some
errors in
sentence
structure,
grammar and
spelling; is in
Word memo
template.
Memo is not
well organized,
and/or contains
several
grammar
and/or spelling
errors; and/or is
not in Word
memo
template.
Memo is
extremely
poorly written
and does not
convey the
information.
TOTAL
Points
Possible
03/15/2019
Possible
Points
100
Purchase answer to see full
attachment