Central Texas College Employee Integrity Tests and Testing Opponents Discussion

User Generated

Ogf10

Business Finance

Central Texas College

Description

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Question 1 () In no less than 300 words (total), answer the following questions. Please organize your answers accordingly so that they are clearly organized for review (e.g. A...B...C...). A. What are the purported purposes of integrity tests for employees? What are the primary criticisms of such tests? Give an example of how an employer might commit disparate impact discrimination through an integrity test. B. What are the purported purposes of personality tests for employees? What are the primary criticisms of such tests? Give an example of how an employer might commit disparate impact discrimination through an personality test. C. What types of cognitive skills tests are commonly used for employee screening? When are and aren't such tests appropriate? Give an example of how an employer might commit disparate impact discrimination through an cognitive skills test. Question 2 In no less than 300 words (total), answer the following questions. Please organize your answers accordingly so that they are clearly organized for review (e.g. A...B...C...). A. What is vicarious liability? What is the reasoning behind holding employers accountable in this way? What are the criteria that determine whether or not vicarious liability will attach? B. Give an example of an employment scenario in which an employer would be responsible for the actions of an employee under vicarious liability. Give an example of an employment scenario in which an employer would not be responsible for the actions of an employee under vicarious liability. C. What were the issues in contention in the infamous Christensen v. Swenson case? How did the court rule in this case, and why?
Purchase answer to see full attachment
User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Explanation & Answer

View attached explanation and answer. Let me know if you have any questions.

Q1
Part A
Employee integrity tests are a type of personality test intended to assess a candidate's
honesty, dependability, and work ethic in the workplace. They are available in two varieties:
overt and covert. Overt integrity tests are those that are used to identify counterproductive
and dishonest behavior such as theft, absenteeism among others Covert testing is based on a
person's personality. They evaluate integrity through the use of proxies such as
conscientiousness.
According to integrity testing opponents, it is unfair to refuse to hire someone because they
have a propensity to do something that they may or may not do; integrity testing can
contravene moral and legal privacy standards since some queries may not be associated with
particular job duties; and 3) there is no protection against the illegal use of data (Landy &
Conte, 2009). The use of integrity tests would have the unintended consequence of screening
out a greater proportion of members of minority groups. Clients' morale may be adversely
affected if they learn of their own score, but even if the scores are only shown to employers,
their attitude toward the employee may be influenced, which may in turn undermine their
ability to perform their jobs effectively.
According to the 1964 Civil Rights Acts under Title VII, all integrity tests are legal provided
that they do not promote any form of discrimination based on race, nationality, color, sex, or
religion. An employer is likely committing disparate impact discrimination for example
he/she alters the scores, adjusts the employment results, and/or uses different cutoffs of the
candidates with the aim of either hiring or retaining a particular people of a given sex,
religion or national origin.
Part B

Identifying the best candidates to assume a given job position requires most companies to
develop new ways of screening, assessing and selecting their candidates so that they may
successfully hire the right person for the job (Schultz & Schultz, 2001). Personality is a
scientifically proven determinant of job success, and examining candidates' behavioral
patterns in the workplace allows recruiters to determine whether they will be high performers
and fit into the company's culture.
While personality test may indeed help recruiters find out some particular characteristics of
interest in a candidate, it may fail to accurately depicts the character of a person. The picture
conveyed during the whole processes of evaluation may be distorted and misleading. Besides,
this method simply confirms the bias of what is expected by the employer since the
personality assessment is meant to confirms evidence rather than questioning the validity of
the evidence.
As mentioned before, personality test should be free from any form of discrimination as per
Title VII. However, an employer may find him/herself committing disparate impact
discrimination if he/she thinks ...


Anonymous
I use Studypool every time I need help studying, and it never disappoints.

Studypool
4.7
Indeed
4.5
Sitejabber
4.4

Related Tags