accounting and experience with web-based course delivery and
instructional technology are highly desirable. Learning Management
System experience preferred, Moodle experience highly preferred.
Ability to use Sage 50/QuickBooks and SAP software is very
desirable.
To Apply
greatest strengths (which he answered as programming Skills) and nis
greatest weakness (he didn't have one prepared to discuss) were. Walter
considered this a structured interview since one of the interviewers from
Small-Time College said she was responsible for asking certain questions.
After working for three years at Small-Time College, Walter felt he had a
good personality-job fit, since he was a valuable member of the
Information Technology Department. Walter also felt he had proven he
had good ability-job fit, since his three years of experience as a computer
programmer at the college proved he had the skills to complete the job.
Most important, Walter felt he had a perfect person-organization fit, since
he was liked by everyone at the college and fit in very well in the
educational culture.
Send cover letter, transcripts, CV/résumé, a statement of teaching
philosophy and contact information for three (3) professional references
(as Word or PDF attachments) via email to: bannisterm@.edu or by
regular mail to Dr. Maxwell Bannister, Chair of the Division of
Business, Small-Time College, 291 Golf Ball Street, Carlsbad, CA
01050.
Review of applications begins immediately and will continue until the
position is filled.
Recently, Walter was contacted by someone on LinkedIn to apply for a
new position at Google. Like everyone else, Walter had heard stories that
Google was a great place to work. He even watched the movie The Intern
to get a better glimpse of what takes place at Google.
Case Questions
Walter also researched the company (using Google Search) and found out
Google uses a unique way to find and match people with jobs at the
amazing company.3
1. What would be a good personality fit for an accounting professor at
Small-Time College?
2. Should the preliminary screening process result in a top 10 of
applicants?
3. What is the role of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection
Process (UGESP)?
4. Which step did the case skip in regard to the steps in the selection
process?
5. Why are background checks harder to conduct than it might appear?
First, Google used its extremely creative way of thinking to create a vice-
president of people operations. Like most companies, Walter's current
employer calls this position the vice-president of human resources.
Case 6.2. Looking for "Organizational Fit”:
Walter's Unstructured Interview at Google
Second, Google uses its data analysis skills to analyze vast amounts of
data about what works and what doesn't work during the hiring process.
One result they found was that interviews had a zero relationship with the
success the person actually had on the job. Consequently, Google doesn't
believe in the traditional metrics used in the hiring process. These
traditional metrics include GPA, SAT scores, or the prestige of college the
candidate attended. Instead, creative companies like Google measure a
candidate on behaviors, such as their level of happiness, ability to work
well with other people, if they like a challenge, if they seek information,
and if they are willing to adapt.4
Walter was proud to earn his bachelor's degree in computer science from
Small-Time College in California. That was almost three years ago, and he
felt as if it was even longer since the field of computer science changes so
quickly.
Walter was able to find a nice “Comp Sci” job at Small-Time College. He
interviewed for the job and remembers the key questions were what his
Walter spoke to the assistant in people operations and set up an interview
for one week later. He was warmly received by Google and quickly fell in
love with the colorful and wide open layout of the headquarters. In a
casual and relaxed atmosphere, he sat down with three different Google
employees and basically explained how he grew up in California and what
52
53
led him down the path of computer science.
Walter thought he might be asked one of those out-of-the-box interview
questions, such as how many gasoline stations would you expect to find in
a city of 160,000 people. But his research also uncovered that Google felt
these types of questions were biased since they tended to just make the
interviewer look smart since they had time to work out the answers.
Google organizational culture. He felt he had a good personality-JOD TIT
since he demonstrated in the interviews that he was an outgoing computer
programmer who would work well with Google's unique corporate
culture. Walter also felt he was a great candidate in regard to ability-job fit
since his three years of experience in his current programming job showed
he could apply his technical skills as a computer programmer in a work
environment. Walter also felt he was a good person-organization fit since
he would work very well within Google's creative-organizational culture.
In the end, Walter was happy to grow from the experience of trying to get
a job at Google. He definitely had more appreciation for his current job
since his employer had been smart enough to give him a job three years
before. He was ready to repay that by doing an excellent job going into the
future.
Since Walter wanted to be a good match, he went with the flow of the
interview and became much more relaxed than he could remember in his
interview with his current company. He expressed how he liked being
happy at work, enjoyed programming computers with a team of
employees, and especially enjoyed interacting with clients to help them
solve their problems. Walter enjoyed the unstructured interview and fel
was doing a good job interacting with the Google interviewers. He
expected the Google interview was going to a least be a semi-structured
interview, which would combine some preplanned and some unplanned
questions. However, the Google interviewers appeared to not have any
prepared questions and instead asked all unplanned questions.
Case Questions
Walter went on to explain how he had been promoted three times in three
years and enjoyed the challenge each positioned offered. He liked the “go
for it attitude” at his present employer. Walter also knew from his research
that Google liked outgoing, happy employees that worked well with their
fellow workers and customers.
1. What do you think the vice president of people actually does at
Google?
2. Did Walter experience a structured, semistructured, or unstructured
interview when he first left college?
3. What are your own greatest strengths and weaknesses as a prospective
employee?
4. How would you answer if someone in HR asked you an unstructured
question such as how many gas stations there are in a city of 160,000?
5. Design a form to help Google compare different candidates. HINT:
You can list some different names of people in the rows. The column
headings need to represent the areas where Google is looking for in an
interview (Happy Employees, Employees Willing to Take on a
Challenge, Creative Employees, etc.)
6. Why do you think Google felt Walter was not a good organizational fit
for the company?
In the end, Walter did not get the job for reasons he never learned.
Although he was disappointed, he also knew that Facebook once turned
down Brian Acton for a job and he went on to co-found WhatsApp which
he sold to Facebook for $19 billion.5 Walter hoped a similar fate was in
his future and he could one day sell his ideas to Google.
Notes
Walter went back to his current job with renewed passion and energy. He
was excited to have spent time at Google and hoped to bring back some of
what he learned and apply it to his own job and division. He also intended
to work closer than ever with his own Human Resources Department to
look for opportunities in his current company. He was hoping to find a
“fast track” program that would speed up his own development, so he
could create a more open and creative company culture along the way.
1 http://www.uniformguidelines.com/uniformguidelines.html.
2 Lu, Andrew, “5 Tips to Keep Reference Checks Legal,” FindLaw.com,
December 12, 2012.
Walter always wondered what his life would have been like if he had been
hired by Google. He thought he was going to be an excellent fit in the
3 Nisen, Max, “Moneyball at Work: They've Discovered What Really
54
55
Purchase answer to see full
attachment