SIMON COMPANY
Simon Company is one of the major producers of generic and store brand hand and body
lotion cream. There is generally not much difference in Simon’s products across different
store brands. The total production capacity is 30,000,000 units per year. The company has
always been profitable except in the last two years when it lost almost $500,000 each year.
Exhibit 1 presents the financial picture for Year 2018.
Exhibit 1
Average selling price per unit
Total manufacturing fixed cost
Average variable manufacturing cost per unit
Total marketing and administrative fixed costs
Average variable marketing and administrative cost per unit
Sales in units
Production in units
No beginning or ending inventories.
Operating loss
$2.00
$8,400,000
$1.00
$600,000
$0.50
17,000,000 units
17,000,000 units
($500,000)
Simon’s current CEO resigned in December of Year 2018 under pressure from the board of
directors. The board approached a competent outside executive Stan Fox to turn-around the
company. Stan was an optimistic soul and agreed to become CEO at the same salary as the
departing CEO. However, his contract provided for a year-end bonus amounting to 20% of
operating income (before considering the bonus or income taxes) for the first year and 10%
thereafter. The annual income is to be certified by a public accounting firm.
Stan, filled with rosy expectations, promptly raised the advertising budget by $1,600,000 and
stepped up production to an annual rate of 25,000,000 units ("to fill the pipelines," he said).
The advertising campaign was launched immediately. Sales for 2019 increased -- but only to
a level of 20,000,000 units.
On the last day of 2019 (soon after the end of year board and audit committee meeting), Stan
resigned to take a job with another corporation having difficulties similar to those that Simon
1
27
Company had a year ago. Stan remarked, "I enjoy challenges. Now that Simon Company is
in the black, I'd prefer tackling another knotty difficulty."
The certified income statement for 2019 contained the following data:
Sales
Production cost
Total
Less: Inventory (5,000,000 units)
$40,000,000
$33,400,000
6,680,000
Cost of goods sold
Gross margin
Marketing and administrative expenses
Operating income
$26,720,000
$13,280,000
$12,200,000
$1,080,000
Questions:
1. As a member of the board of directors, evaluate the current year's operating income and
the CEO’s performance?
2. Going forward, what would you recommend for company’s operating policies and the
CEO’s incentive contract?
2
28
Simon Company incurred a loss of 500,000 for the year 2018. The loss was brought
about by the decrease in sales in 2018 and incurred higher variable and fixed costs. The
assignment of Stan Fox as CEO helped the company to increase its sales in 2019. The
CEO has made an effort to market and advertise the product to generate more sales and
thus, maximize income. Revenue generation and production improved, enabling the CEO to
maximize resources even if planned production was not 100% realized(30,000,000). The
increase in costs is justified by the revenue generated, or by matching the total cumulative
revenue, which is why revenue is still generated. The operating income of Simon Company
has increased in 2019 and the company earned a profit out of it. The performance was
good and the CEO is performing well since he was able to develop strategies on how to
increase sales.
The CEO's performance was indeed very remarkable since he was able to help the
company cover its loss over the past two years. The company earned 1,080,000 operating
income in 2019 with a 316% increase in income based on 2018. Due to this result, the CEO
was able to improve operational profitability as well as efficiency. Profitability is the sense
that the CEO was able to turn a loss into profit through its marketing strategy which is a
good thing for the firm.
2018 Sales
=17,000,000 x 2
$34,000,000
Variable manufacturing cost
= 17,000,000 x 1
$17,000,000
Variable marketing & admin
= 17,000,000 x 0.50 $8,500,000
Fixed costs
$8,400,000
Marketing & admin costs $600,000
Operating loss
$-500,000
34,000,000-17,000,000-8,500,000-8,400,000-600,000 = -500,000 operating loss
Purchase answer to see full
attachment