Discussion 7 Response
First Post by Student
Discussion 7 by Ken Barnes
Good morning, Linda Lawyer. Have I got a legal mess for you to figure
out. We had an incident last week with one of our teenage drivers
speeding while making a delivery, then was arrested because,
unbeknownst to us, the package in her possession contained drugs,
which we are not licensed to deliver. Our driver, Tammy is also not
allowed to possess such packages, because she is a minor, even if we
were licensed. Since we were unable to deliver the package, the
customer, Vicki Vegetable did not submit a payment for our invoice.
A couple of days ago, Vicki called, and I was in no mood to talk to her,
so I asked Tammy to talk to her. Well, thinking she was doing the
company a favor because she was arrested for possession, agreed to
terms with Vicki to meet her niece in Chicago who was supposed to
give Tammy half of the payment in cash. However, when Tammy
arrived, she was handed a construction contract which was illegally
transferred to us for a new building in Chicago, using Tammy as the
transferee. However, the contractor needs money from us to complete
the building.
The first issue is that the shipping contract should be void
because it is illegal for us to transport drugs, since we are not properly
licensed. Then, there is the issue of Tammy being a minor. She was not
authorized to make any payment arrangements with Vicki, even though
her heart was in the right place. Tammy did not have the capacity to
enter into a payment agreement, and will disaffirm that contract. Vicki
exerted undue influence over Tammy by taking advantage of Tammy’s
willingness to make right of the situation. Since the agreement was to
settle a debt owed us by Vicki Vegetable, Tammy should not be liable
for any restitution.
She went to Chicago expecting to receive a cash payment, and instead
received a building contract which was already altered by replacing any
reference to Vicki Vegetable with Tammy’s initials. Since the building
contract was fraudulently altered, and given to Tammy without her
understanding of what it meant, we should also not be liable to the
contractor to pay for the completion of the building. Also the
contractor did not agree to the altered contract. Additionally, the value
of a building in Chicago is unjust enrichment for a few hundred dollar
shipping invoice.
I believe we are due damages from Vicki in the amount of the original
invoice and any subsequent legal and court costs we may incur as a
result of her actions.
References
Clarkson, K. W., & Miller, R. L. (2021, 2018). Business Law: Text and
Cases (15th ed.). Australia, Brazil, Mexico, Singapore, United Kingdom,
United States: Cengage Learning.
Jackson, N. (2022, February 10). (K. Barnes, Interviewer)
Second Post by Student
Discussion 7 by Steeve Bruny
We need your expert opinion about a situation. Our driver, Tammy, got
pulled over for speeding while transporting a shipment to a client for
us. The shipment was contained drugs. Consequently, our driver was
arrested, and we did not get paid for the shipment. I would like to
know how our Company can avoid this kind of situation in the future.
We want to avoid trouble with the law to keep our employees safe, and
customers satisfied. We need to know legal whether there is licensing
process that allows our Company to transport drugs legally.
Furthermore, our driver agrees to waive half of the amount due over
the phone. We would like to understand the legality of the decision she
made on our Company's behalf. Additionally, Tammy signed a contract
on our behalf that completely changed our contract structure with our
client. I believed they took advantage of her gullibility. Could this
situation be considered fraudulent misrepresentation or negligent
misrepresentation?
Lastly, Charlie Contractor, the Company we now have to deal with,
demands more money before continuing the work. This demand goes
against our previous contract. How do I convince them to respect our
previous agreement? Forbes Solicitors (n.d.) explained that a remedy
that may be available for fraudulent misrepresentation or negligent
misrepresentation is recission. This remedy sets aside the contract and
puts the party in the position before the agreement.
Reference
Forbes Solicitors. (n.d.). Misrepresentation: What is it, and what remedies
are available? Forbes Solicitors. Retrieved February 11, 2022, from
https://www.forbessolicitors.co.uk/news/47588/misrepresentationwhat-is-it-and-what-remedies-are-available
Purchase answer to see full
attachment