Time remaining:
Why did Kuhn consider the phlogiston episode to be a case of paradigm change

Philosophy
Tutor: None Selected Time limit: 1 Day

I know what a paradigm change is and what the phlogiston theory is, I am just struggling to find out why Kuhn considered it as a paradigm change. Is it because he discovered oxygen? Which changed everything?

Apr 8th, 2015

Kuhn believes that fundamental shifts in science occur more as a result of learning to see phenomena from a whole new perspective instead of through detailed, point-by-point argumentation and likewise when he does philosophy he invites readers to share his philosophical conceptual scheme rather than pounding away at other philosophical views. Thus, in a famous confrontation with Popper in 1965, he begins by commenting on Popper's metaphors rather than by trying to analyze, sharpen, and argue about their points of disagreement.
Kuhn's mode of philosophizing makes it very difficult for critics to pin down exactly what his position is. In a later section we will review some of the major issues his work has raised, such as the problems of incommensurability and the rationality of normal science. But let me begin in a Kuhnian fashion by presenting a brief case study from the history of science in such a way that it may serve as an exemplar of Kuhnian scientific development, namely the Copernican Revolution. In doing so, I do not mean to imply that an interpretation of this episode from the perspective of Kuhn's philosophy is the correct or the best way to view it. Neither do I claim that Kuhn's own historical work on the Copernican Revolution is intended to buttress his later philosophical theory. He is much too good a historian to write history using any philosophical formula - even his own.

Apr 10th, 2015

Are you studying on the go? Check out our FREE app and post questions on the fly!
Download on the
App Store
...
Apr 8th, 2015
...
Apr 8th, 2015
Dec 11th, 2016
check_circle
Mark as Final Answer
check_circle
Unmark as Final Answer
check_circle
Final Answer

Secure Information

Content will be erased after question is completed.

check_circle
Final Answer