Description
Essay Elements:
- One to three pages of scholarly writing in paragraph format, not counting the title page or reference page
- Brief introduction of the case
- Identification of the main diagnosis with supporting rationale
- Identification of at least two additional differential diagnoses with brief rationale for why these were ruled out
- Diagnostic plan with supporting rationale or references
- A specific treatment plan supported by recent clinical guidelines
Please refer to the rubric for point value and requirements. In general, these elements must be covered as per the rubric:
Aquifer Essay Outline
Patient Name: Savannah North
- Age: 16
- Sex assigned at birth: female
- Gender identity: female
- Pronouns: she/her/hers
- Preferred language of communication: English
You are working at an outpatient family medicine clinic with Dr. Hill. She has asked you to interview and examine Savannah North, a 16-year-old who has come in for a routine sports physical before the softball season begins. Her mother, Leslie, accompanies her.
Dr. Hill informs you, "This is one of the special aspects I love about family medicine: I have cared for Savannah and her entire family since I helped Leslie deliver Savannah 16 years ago!"
She continues, "Today, in addition to performing a pre-participation physical examination, I would like to use this opportunity to perform prevention screening and counseling since this type of visit is often the only time we see adolescents. Perhaps the most important 'screening' issue is the medical interview and developing a safe and trusting doctor-patient relationship. Since this can sometimes be challenging with adolescents, I have found it helpful to organize my interview around the adolescent interviewing mnemonic, HEEADSSS."
Logistically, you both decide that it would be best to begin the medical interview with Savannah's mother present and then delve into details and sensitive information after inviting her mother to wait in the waiting room.
Dr. Hill reminds you, "Along with the psychosocial medical interview, we will want to consider prevention screening. First, you need to decide whether a screening test is worth ordering. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) has taken the qualities of a good screening test into account when they make recommendations of what screening tests we should do. Let's take chlamydia for example and look online together and see what they have to say about chlamydia screening in a 16-year-old, such as Savannah."
After discussing preventive screening, you and Dr. Hill review the sports pre-participation questionnaire that Savannah filled out in the waiting room.
Then, Dr. Hill tells you, "I think you are ready to go meet Savannah and her mother."
You enter the room and see Savannah, a tall, athletic, 16-year-old, sitting with her mother.
You introduce yourself and explain, "Dr. Hill and I have been reviewing your sports pre-participation questionnaire together.
HEEADSSS ASSESSMENT
You then turn to Leslie and ask, "I would like to speak with Savannah alone for a few minutes now." Leslie excuses herself from the room. With the HEEADSSS mnemonic in mind, you continue your conversation with Savannah. You explain to Savannah that everything discussed here is confidential.
During continued conversation, Savannah mentions several of her friends have begun to smoke cigarettes, but she does not like the taste of them. Similarly, neither she nor her female friends have experimented with dietary supplements or steroids, although she does know some on the baseball team who have tried them. She maintains a healthy diet and feels satisfied with her current weight and shape.
Savannah goes on to describe two other male sexual partners in the past and says that she uses condoms "most of the time" but reports no other methods of contraception. She admits that the possibility of pregnancy worries her. She has had no sexually transmitted infections that she knows of.
You then ask Savannah if she has any further questions and tell her that Dr. Hill will have more questions when you all come back. You excuse yourself while she changes clothes for the physical exam.
On your way out the door, you remember that the preventive exam is an important opportunity to update immunizations. You tell Savannah, "By the way, Dr. Hill may recommend some shots today." She responds with a groan, but she nods her head in assent.
REVIEWING IMMUNIZATIONS
In the hallway, while waiting to present Savannah's interview to Dr. Hill, you review her immunization record.
Vaccine | Dose 1 date | Dose 2 date | Dose 3 date | Dose 4 date | Dose 5 date | Dose 6 date | Total doses |
DTP, DTAP, DT, TD, TDAP | 2 months | 4 months | 6 months | 15 months | 18 months | 5 | |
IPV | 2 months | 4 months | 6 months | 18 months | 4 | ||
Hib (Under age 5) | 2 months | 4 months | 6 months | 12 months | 4 | ||
Measles, Mumps, Rubella (MMR) | 12 months | 4 years | 2 | ||||
Varicella | 16 months | 1 | |||||
Hep A | 12 years | 12.5 years | 2 | ||||
Hep B | at birth | 2 months | 6 months | 3 | |||
HPV | 12 years | 12.5 years | 2 | ||||
MCV or MPSV | |||||||
PCV 13 | 2 months | 4 months | 6 months | 12 months | 4 | ||
Rotavirus | 2 months | 4 months | 2 | ||||
Influenza | 15 years | 1 | |||||
COVID-19 | 15 years |
You also take a moment to look over the CDC's recommended immunization schedule for persons aged 7 through 18 years in the U.S. on your computer.
The best options are indicated below. Your selections are indicated by the shaded boxes.
- A. Flu
- G. Meningococcal (MCV)
- H. Tetanus, Diphtheria, Pertussis (Tdap)
- I. Varicella
TRAUMA-INFORMED CARE EXCELLENCE IN ACTION
You find Dr. Hill and present the interview and relevant findings, including your recommendations for Tdap, MCV, and varicella. You and Dr. Hill also conclude that as a sexually active woman under 25, she should be screened for chlamydia and gonorrhea according to the US Preventive Service Task Force "B"recommendation.
Dr. Hill praises you, "The adolescent interview can be challenging. You obviously developed a rapport with Savannah and conducted a thorough adolescent interview. I’m glad you started the discussion about intimate partner violence with Savannah. We now know that Intimate partner violence is very common, and can start with first sexual experiences.
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH SCREENING
After greeting Savannah, Dr. Hill walks you through a routine preparticipation sports physical exam. After she has finished the exam, Dr. Hill says, "Your examination shows that you are healthy. I have a few follow-up questions before your mom comes back in."
After discussing various options for birth control, Savannah indicates that she wants to start injectable medroxyprogesterone acetate (Depo-ProveraTM) because it will be easier than "remembering to take pills every day," but wants the chance to go home and discuss things with her mother first. She plans to schedule her follow-up visit with you in a week and will let you know her final decision then.
You refer her to familydoctor.org for more information on contraceptive options.
You let Savannah know that she needs three vaccines today and that the varicella vaccine is a live, attenuated vaccine and ideally would feature a one-month period before she conceived, so the birth control discussion really is important and relevant. You advise her to use condoms for each sexual encounter until she returns for her Depo-Provera shot.
Dr. Hill lets Savannah know that the US Preventive Services Task Force has the highest recommendation of "A" for her to start folic acid. The USPSTF says all persons who could become pregnant take a daily supplement of 0.4-0.4 (400-800mcg) of folic acid daily to prevent severe congenital abnormalities of the spinal cord (neural tube defects). She can avoid getting pregnant by remaining abstinent until she starts contraception.
After bringing Savannah's mother, Leslie, back for an update on the sports physical and immunizations, the visit is concluded. Savannah plans to call for a follow-up visit after talking with her mother.
RETURN VISIT TWO WEEKS LATER
Two weeks later, Savannah returns to discuss her first Depo-Provera injection and chlamydia and gonorrhea screening. When you go to see her, you notice Savannah is alone. You greet her and catch up a bit, and then you turn your attention to more details about her menstrual history.
ORDERING UCG
After you update Dr. Hill on the interval history, you return to the exam room together.
Dr. Hill Greets Savannah:
"Alright, I just wanted to be sure. You can always feel safe to share anything with me. Let's take this one step at a time. First, why don't we check a urine pregnancy test? We will also test your urine sample for chlamydia and gonorrhea as we planned on doing. Then, we'll have some information that we can sit down and review together.
You and Dr. Hill wait in the hall while Savannah collects a urine sample for the urinary human chorionic gonadotropin (UCG) testing and a urine PCR for chlamydia and gonorrhea, and then returns to the exam room.
DELIVERING THE RESULTS
When the nurse hands you the results of the test, you accompany Dr. Hill back into the examination room.
Dr. Hill begins: "Savannah, your urine pregnancy test is positive. You are pregnant." She pauses.
“I know that’s a lot to take in. How are you feeling about that news?”
Savannah says,
“I can’t say I’m surprised because I was feeling afraid that was the case. But I feel really shaken.”
Savannah asks,
"How far along am I?"
"What should I do?"
"What is the procedure if I want to end the pregnancy?"
"What is the fetus like right now? Is an abortion still legal at this point?"
DISCUSSING INITIAL LAB TESTS
Dr. Hill says, "I can appreciate that you are in a difficult situation. Nevertheless, I think it is wise for you not to jump into making any decisions right this moment. I recommend that you take time to consider all of your options. It is a good idea for you to go home and talk to your parents and your boyfriend about this. Do you feel comfortable doing that?"
Savannah responds, "Yes, they will be upset, but I can talk to them."
Dr. Hill continues, "Please feel free to call me if you have any questions. Even though I know that you are overwhelmed, you aren't the first young woman to be in a similar situation. I can point you toward some people who can help and also to some good resources if you would like more information. I would like you to come back in one week. You can bring your parents or your partner if you like, and we will discuss your options further, then when you have had a chance to think about things. All right?"
Savannah, although initially shaken, now appears reassured. She nods her head in agreement.
Dr. Hill concludes, "In the meantime, it is recommended to do a few blood tests today, just to make sure you don't have any sexually transmitted infections like HIV, or other types of diseases that could affect pregnancy. Additionally, should you decide to continue your pregnancy, I would recommend taking a prenatal vitamin. Do you have any questions for me?"
Savannah replies, "No, that's fine. Oh, and Dr. Hill. One more thing. The handout for the chickenpox vaccine said that I should not take the vaccine if I was planning on getting pregnant within the next month. I wasn't planning on this. But what could happen to the baby? Why would they warn us about this?"
Dr. Hill replies, "That's a good question, Savannah. Although a case of a birth defect in a fetus caused by the mother receiving the varicella vaccine has never been documented, getting the actual chickenpox illness naturally while pregnant has been attributed to some birth defects. So we are just really cautious. You don't need to do anything. It is routine for us to report this to the health department. But I wouldn't give this any more thought than this, okay?"
Savannah, "Ok, thank you."
Dr. Hill fills out a lab slip and hands it to Savannah. After you have directed her to the lab, she heads out.
RETURN VISIT: VAGINAL BLEEDING
About one week later, the nurse, Mary, tells you, "Savannah called earlier complaining of vaginal bleeding. She said that she was not hurting, but she sounded worried. After talking with her I didn't get the impression that her bleeding warranted going to the emergency room. I told her to go ahead and come here first. When Dr. Hill comes out of that room, tell her I'm going to go ahead and have Savannah in a gown. Oh, her mother is with her today too."
As you are waiting on Dr. Hill, the nurse brings you Savannah's labs from last week.
Labs
- CBC (WBC 8.4 x 103/mm3, Hgb 12.7 g/dl, Hct 37.4%, Plt 270)
- Rubella immune
- Hepatitis B surface antigen negative
- Blood type: O negative, Rh antibody negative
- RPR non-reactive
- HIV negative
- Gonorrhea/chlamydia PCR negative
A few moments later, Dr. Hill joins you and comments: "Obviously, I am concerned about this bleeding, but before we delve off into searching for the differential diagnosis and pathophysiological source, let's remember some fundamentals. Two of the most urgent pieces of information about first-trimester bleeding are contained in the vital signs."
Vital signs:
- Temperature is 37.2 C (99 F)
- Pulse is 85 beats/minute
- Blood pressure is 102/70 mmHg
HISTORY AND PHYSICAL EXAM
You and Dr. Hill greet Savannah and her mother, Leslie. Dr. Hill begins:Savannah's mother, Leslie, interjects, "Doctor, we are worried that this is a miscarriage. How will we know and is there anything that we can do?""I understand that is a concern. You should know that some sort of bleeding is relatively common during the first trimester. Incidentally, bleeding does not necessarily mean that you are having a miscarriage."Dr. Hill continues, "However, before I can give you a more educated answer about what may be the source of your bleeding, I need to ask you a few more questions, perform a brief examination, and perhaps obtain some diagnostic lab work and imaging."
"Savannah, I will do a pelvic exam in order to gather all the information we need to assess what is happening. I am going to insert a small instrument called a speculum into your vagina to begin the pelvic examination. This instrument will allow me to see your cervix. Then, I will use my gloved hand and examine your vagina, cervix, uterus, and ovaries directly. If you are hurting or uncomfortable at any point, please let me know. Are you ready?"
Savannah nods her head.
After washing her hands and applying gloves, Dr. Hill then approaches the patient as she described above and proceeds to a focused and appropriate physical exam.
Physical Exam
- General: well-developed and athletic, but anxious adolescent
- CV: regular rate and rhythm, 2/6 soft decrescendo murmur in early systole
- Abdomen: normal bowel sounds on auscultation, non-tender during auscultation, and to both percussion and palpation; the uterine fundus was not palpable on the abdominal exam due to the gestation age
- Genital exam: normal appearing labia without visible lesions. The speculum exam showed a minimal amount of fresh blood in the posterior fornix. The vaginal sidewall was pink and moist, without obvious signs of trauma. The cervix revealed mild ectropion, no obvious masses or lesions, and appeared to be undilated. Both a wet prep for trichomonas and tests gonorrhea, and chlamydia were obtained. On bimanual exam, the cervix was closed, the uterus was felt to be less than eight weeks size, and nontender. There were no adnexal masses palpable. Additionally, there was no cervical motion, tenderness, or adnexal tenderness.
As Dr. Hill re-drapes Savannah and helps her sit up, she informs her: "Savannah, I did see a little bit of blood, but nothing else I saw was conclusive… and that is not at all unusual. You can get dressed and we will do some diagnostic testing; an ultrasound and some lab work. The results will be back this morning, so we can review everything today."
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Later that morning, Savannah's laboratory and imaging comes back with the following results:
Labs
- CBC: WBC = 9.3 x103/μL (9.3 x109/L), Hgb = 12.1 g/dL (121 g/L), Hct = 36.3% (0.36), Platelets = 176000/mm3( 176 x109/L)
- Wet prep: no trichomonas, no yeast, no clue cells
- GC/chlamydia: pending
- Quantitative beta-hCG = 1492 mIU/mL
- Progesterone = 14.5 nmol/L
Transabdominal and transvaginal ultrasound report:
- No intrauterine pregnancy is noted
- Left ovarian cyst 3cm
- Cannot rule out ectopic pregnancy
- B. Ectopic pregnancy
- C. Idiopathic bleeding in a viable pregnancy
- E. Spontaneous abortion (miscarriage)
EXPLAINING THE RESULTS
It is almost noon when the nurse accompanies Savannah and Leslie back into the exam room. Dr. Hill invites you to join her as she enters the room.Savannah asks:
FOLLOW-UP TESTING
Two days later, Savannah returns to the clinic with her mother. Her serial quantitative beta-hCG was drawn earlier today and the results are back from the lab.
Labs
- Quantitative beta-hCG = 2900 mIU/mL
Vital signs:
- Temperature is 36.9 C (98.4 F)
- Pulse is 87 beats/minute
- Blood pressure is 107/72 mmHg
During the interview, Savannah tells you and Dr. Hill that her bleeding stopped and the pain and cramping subsided two days ago, shortly after she left the office.
Dr. Hill confirms that while bleeding and pain subsiding is always a comforting sign, they are not sufficient to reassure us that everything is fine yet. She also explains to Savannah that her increasing hormone level (quantitative hCG), while not conclusive, makes an intrauterine pregnancy more likely and an ectopic slightly less likely. She recommends repeating the lab work in two to three days.
Savannah persists, "Could we get an answer if you did another vaginal ultrasound? I'm not sure I can survive much more uncertainty."
Dr. Hill performs a transvaginal ultrasound. (See the images below.)
DISCUSSING THE ULTRASOUND
After seeing the ultrasound, Savannah seems visibly relieved.
Dr. Hill asks her:
"I think that you are a remarkable young woman, Savannah. You are brave, strong, intelligent, and you have a loving family, who are going to help you through this, whatever course of action you decide to pursue."
As Dr. Hill helps Savannah cover herself and reposition, you print a photograph from the machine for Savannah. Dr. Hill explains that she would like to see Savannah in two to four weeks for follow-up for a routine prenatal visit. She reassures her and her mother about the ultrasound findings but reminds them that if the bleeding returns or there is significant pain, dizziness, lightheadedness, or fainting, they should call her office or after-hours answering service. They will page her immediately. Finally, she reminds her to continue taking her prenatal vitamins daily.
EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT VISIT
Ten days later, you are covering the emergency room with Dr. Hill. The nurse approaches you to inform Dr. Hill that Savannah is here:
Nursing Note: Patient presenting with vaginal bleeding. Her mother says that she is two months pregnant. Her vital signs are BP 105/75 mmHg, pulse of 90 beats/minute, and a temperature of 36.9 C (98.4 F)."
Dr. Hill thanks the nurse and asks you to accompany her. As you enter the room, Savannah recognizes you and begins to cry. She tells you she has been bleeding on and off for about an hour, with some clots, and a fair amount of pain, but when you ask she tells you she hasn't had any dizziness or light-headedness.
Dr. Hill says, "Savannah, we need to examine your abdomen and cervix like we did a few weeks ago in the office. Like before, it will involve the speculum to allow us to see, then it will involve a hand in your vagina and another on your abdomen. Is it all right with you if the student performs the exam?"
Savannah responds, "That's fine. I don't have any questions yet."
Dr. Hill assists you in performing a pelvic exam. You find:
Pelvic Exam: Some pooled blood in the vaginal vault. On both the speculum and digital exam, the os appears to be opened to about 1-2 cm. Her abdominal exam reveals normal bowel sounds on auscultation, no tenderness on palpation, and is soft.
Dr. Hill then states to Savannah and Leslie, "I'm going to ask the ultrasound technician to perform another ultrasound, that will allow me to assess the fetus' heart rate. We should be able to obtain the ultrasound images through your lower abdomen this time."
Several minutes later, you and Dr. Hill are called to the ultrasound room.
Abdominal Ultrasound: No detectable fetal heart rate. The fetus' crown-rump length measures 0.65 cm, or approximately 6w4d gestation, similar to the last ultrasound.
"Savannah," Dr. Hill begins, "your fetus does not have a heartbeat. That means that the fetus has died. I'm sorry."
Leslie gently but tearfully indicates that they would like a few moments alone.
Dr. Hill excuses you and herself from the room so you may discuss the findings, promising to return in a moment.
MANAGEMENT OPTIONS
- A. Expectant management
- B. Medical therapy
- C. Surgical management
ED FOLLOW-UP VISIT
About a week later, you are in the office with Dr. Hill, when Savannah is scheduled for a follow-up from her emergency room visit.
Savannah has brought her boyfriend, the father of the baby, to this visit. Upon questioning, she reports that about two days later, she had several hours of pain and bleeding, but it was not worse than her normal menstrual period.
Her vital signs are normal and her hemoglobin is 11.7 g/dL (117 g/L).
Her boyfriend asks:
"Did we do anything wrong? I mean, should we not have had sex when she was pregnant? Would the baby have been okay if she hadn't been playing softball?"
Savannah says: "I'm sad that my baby miscarried, but some part of me also feels relieved, and I feel guilty about that. Is that wrong? You know, I really want to finish school first, but I want children in the future.
Will I have another miscarriage?"
Savannah says, "I will think about that. Thank you both for all of your help, though."
Dr. Hill reminds Savannah, "You were considering Depo-Provera for birth control. Would you like us to get you started on that today?"
Savannah says, "Yes, it would be a good idea to start it today."
Dr. Hill encourages Savannah to return with any questions she may come up with, or if she finds herself having trouble dealing with the grief. You wish Savannah luck, and she and Jim head out the door to the nurse for the Depo-Provera.
Unformatted Attachment Preview
Purchase answer to see full attachment