Paper must be 3-5 pages, double-spaced, typed, and in 12pt. Times New Roman font and in proper ESSAY format (MLA or APA).
Directions: In concise and complete sentences (using essay format), explain your ethical reasoning! To help you form your ethical conclusion, you MUST utilize the theory of ethical egoism. For example, you may say, “I came to this conclusion by utilizing the theory of ethical egoism…” and explain (in detail) how that theory applies. Remember to utilize step-by-step the “ABCD’s of Ethical Decision Making: A Brief Guide,” when writing your paper.
If you wish to quote something directly from the readings, please use the simple format of putting the author’s last name and page number in parenthesis after the quotation and before the period: example – “Philosophy is wonderful” (Author, 1).
Additionally, feel free to use any handouts, power point presentations or posted notes in the Files Directory to help you with this assignment.
Follow precisely the steps below in analyzing this case study.
- How would a person representing ethical egoism advise you in deciding on the
right thing to do in the ethical scenario below? Why would they advise you as
- Next, indicate clearly what you think are the strengths and weaknesses in the
ethical egoist's advice to you.
- Finally, what would you do in this case and why would you act this way if you found yourself in the position of the person who bought the ticket for their neighbor?
"The Lottery Ticket"
Your neighbor, with whom you are friendly but not friends, asks you to buy a random number lottery ticket for them when you are pulling out of your driveway to go to the Royal Farm Store. They say to you laughing, "Just buy my ticket with my dollar and make sure you don't get it mixed up with yours in case mine wins!" "You bet," you say and drive away. At the Royal Farm Store you smile to yourself and decide to actually follow your neighbor's instructions precisely and buy them a “random number” ticket with the dollar they gave you. You then place the ticket in your shirt pocket so that you can remember that it is the ticket you bought for them. You then buy a "set number" ticket for yourself with your own money.
When you get home your neighbor is not around, so you go inside and later learn that the random number ticket you bought for your neighbor with their money won the lottery jackpot of $1.8 million. You could really use the money, as you are behind in your rent, car payments and owe $4,000 on your credit cards - not to mention that you need money to complete your college education. What would you say to your neighbor when they call you asking whether their ticket was the winning ticket? Why would you say that?
Remember: 1. What would an ethical egoist advise to say to your neighbor and why?
2. What would you say to your neighbor and why?