Discussion: "City of Broken Dreams"

User Generated

Gvalnaubzrjbex621

Writing

MIT

Description

Instructions

For this week's discussion, simply find a passage in Goldrick-Rab's essay that caught your attention and provoked a reaction. Quote the passage and share with the class your reaction.

Protocol for Discussion Post: 400 Words-- Minimum

  • In your first sentence, offer the author's full name and the title of the essay
  • In one sentence, offer a summary or overview--what is this essay about
  • Tell the class you found one passage that caught your attention
  • Share with the class where the passage is located. This means you should offer context. For example: Goldrick-Rab offers a section titled "The Milwaukee Price." Here, I found a passage that provoked a reaction from me...
  • Offer the direct quotation with a signal phrase and cite the page number.
  • Share with the class why you chose the passage--connecting with the passage using personal experience or commentary is one way to achieve this.

Initial Discussion Post will be worth up to 16 points.

Protocol for Reply to a Classmate--150 words minimum

The Reply to a Classmate's Post will be worth up to 8 points.

Offer a polite salutation: Hello Sammy,

In at least 150 words explain why you agree or disagree with ideas in you classmate's post.

NOTE:
glasses

Links to an external site.For full credit, since this is a UC:CSU level composition course, your post must be free from minor errors in spelling, punctuation, capitalization and basic mistakes in style and grammar.

Take Your Writing to the Next Level! You Got This!

.

Sentence Strategies

  • Two sentence openers
  • Formal tone

Highlight all of the sentence openers

Here are the sentence openers to experiment with in this week's post.

Sentence Openers

In fact,

Indeed,

To be sure,

Specifically,

To the point,

Clearly,

To be clear,

More importantly,

Can You Show Me How to Use a Direct Quotation?

.

Screen Shot 2022-02-06 at 4.07.54 PM-1.png

To avoid loss of points---use the direct quotation method and cite the location correctly.

Sample citation method for an actual physical book--use a signal phrase with a comma (Goldrick-Rab writes, ) cite the page number and place the period correctly.

Goldrick-Rab writes, "Thus, in 2008, Milwaukee students faced a net price about 19 percent higher than that of students enrolled elsewhere" (254).

Sample citation method for an e-book--cite the paragraph number.

Goldrick-Rab writes, "Thus, in 2008, Milwaukee students faced a net price about 19 percent higher than that of students enrolled elsewhere" (par. 40).

Discussion: City of Broken Dreams

Discussion: City of Broken Dreams

CriteriaRatingsPts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeResponse to prompt.

16 pts

Well Done!

A very thoughtful and robust response to the prompt that correctly integrates one quotation and is free of minor errors in grammar, punctuation, capitalization, spelling, style, etc. You also highlighted the sentence openers.

12 pts

Almost There!

A somewhat thoughtful response but the citation method is flawed AND/OR contains several errors in grammar, punctuation, etc. Did you forget to highlight the sentence openers?

10 pts

Not There Yet--But Don't Give Up!

A citation may be missing. Too brief AND/OR post contains numerous errors in grammar, punctuation, etc. Did you try out two sentence openers?

0 pts

No discussion post.

16 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeReply to classmate.

8 pts

Well Done!

Polite greeting to classmate and a thoughtful response that indicates why you agree or disagree using details.

6 pts

Almost There!

Too brief OR contains numerous errors that make reading difficult.

5 pts

Not There Yet--But Don't Give Up!

Underdeveloped OR marked by several errors. May have forgotten to offer a polite greeting to classmate: Hello Susan, Thank you for your post. I agree (I disagree...)

0 pts

No reply.

8 pts

Total Points: 24

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Explanation & Answer

Attached.

1

Discussion.

Your name
Instructor's name
Course Name and Code.
Date of submission.

2

Discussion Post: Goldrick-Rab’s Essay.
In her essay, City Of Broken Dreams, Sara Goldrick-Rab investigates how low-income
college students are succeeding at obtaining a degree despite financial troubles. But more
importantly, she notes that the promise of higher education as the gateway to economic
mobility is flawed by a host of other systemic barriers, including weak financial aid, high living
costs, and unexpected obstacles. And, as expected, Goldrick-Rab questions the idea that
financial aid alone is enough to get students through. Her essay is indeed a powerful critique
of the American education system, as most students’ dreams of getting a college de...

Related Tags