Benchmark - Change Initiative: Implementation, Evaluation, and Sustainability
2
1
3
4
5
Less than
Unsatisfactory
Satisfactory
Good
Excellent
Satisfactory
0.00%
79.00%
87.00%
100.00%
74.00%
80.0 %Content
The need for
The need for
The need for
The need for change
change
change
change
including
The need for
including
including
including
specifying the
change
specifying the
specifying the
specifying the issue and the
including
issue and the
issue and the
issue and the current
specifying the
current
10.0 % The
current
current
outcomes
issue and the
outcomes
Need for
outcomes
outcomes
resulting from
current
resulting from
Change
resulting from
resulting from the issue is
outcomes
the issue is
the issue is
the issue is
thoroughly
resulting from
included, but
discussed, but
discussed,
discussed with
the issue is not
discussion is
discussion is
including all rich detail,
discussed.
cursory and
incomplete or
necessary
including all
lacking in
inaccurate.
elements.
necessary
depth.
elements.
Description of
Description of Description of
internal and/or
internal and/or internal and/or
Description of
external driving
Description of
external driving external
internal and/or
forces,
internal and/or
forces,
driving forces,
external driving
contributing
external driving
contributing
contributing
forces,
issues, and
5.0 % Driving forces,
issues, and
issues, and
contributing
people affected
Forces
contributing
people affected people
issues, and
is thoroughly
issues, and
is included, but affected is
people affected
discussed with
people affected
discussion is
discussed,
is incomplete
rich detail,
is not included.
cursory and
including all
or inaccurate.
including all
lacking in
necessary
necessary
depth.
elements.
elements.
Evaluation of
Evaluation of Evaluation of
stakeholders
stakeholders
stakeholders
Evaluation of
and how they
Evaluation of
and how they and how they
stakeholders
will be affected
stakeholders
will be affected will be
and how they
by the change
5.0 %
and how they
by the change affected by the
will be affected
initiative is
Stakeholder
will be affected
initiative is
change
by the change
thoroughly
Evaluation
by the change
included, but initiative is
initiative is
discussed with
initiative is not
discussion is
discussed,
incomplete or
rich detail,
included.
cursory and
including all
inaccurate.
including all
lacking in
necessary
necessary
depth.
elements.
elements.
The role of the
The role of the leader in the
The role of the The role of the leader in the change
10.0 % The
The role of the leader in the
leader in the
change
initiative is
Role of the
leader in the
change
change initiative initiative is
thoroughly
Leader in the change
initiative is
is presented, but presented and presented with
Change
initiative is not present, but it is it is cursory and includes
rich detail and
Initiative
addressed.
incomplete or lacking in
discussion of includes
inaccurate.
depth.
all necessary discussion of
elements.
all necessary
elements.
Discussion of
Discussion of Discussion of necessary
Discussion of necessary
necessary
change agents
Discussion of
necessary
change agents change agents and their
necessary
change agents and their
and their
respective roles
change agents
and their
respective roles respective
in
10.0 % Change and their
respective roles in implementing roles in
implementing
Agents and
respective roles
in
change is
implementing change is
Roles
in
implementing included, but change is
thoroughly
implementing
change is
discussion is
discussed,
discussed with
change is not
incomplete or cursory and
including all rich detail,
included.
inaccurate.
lacking in
necessary
including all
depth.
elements.
necessary
elements.
The change
The change
10.0 %
The change
model is
The change
model is
Application of
model is
thoroughly
The change
model is
thoroughly
the Change
applied, but the
applied with
model is not
applied, but the
applied and
Model to
resulting
rich detail and
applied to
resulting
the resulting
Develop
strategies are
the resulting
develop
strategies are
strategies
Strategies
cursory and
strategies
strategies.
incomplete or
include all
(Competency
lacking in
include all
inaccurate.
necessary
3.5)
depth.
necessary
elements.
elements.
Overcoming
Overcoming barriers to
Overcoming
10.0 %
Overcoming
barriers to
change is
barriers to
Overcoming
Overcoming barriers to
change is
thoroughly
change is
Barriers to
barriers to
change is
presented and presented with
presented, but it
Change
change is not presented, but it
includes
rich detail and
is cursory and
(Competency addressed.
is incomplete
discussion of includes
lacking in
1.5)
or inaccurate.
all necessary discussion of
depth.
elements.
all necessary
elements.
10.0 %
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Methods
methods for
methods for
methods for
methods for
determining the determining the determining the determining
success of the success of the success of the the success of
change
change
change initiative the change
initiative are initiative are are included but initiative are
not included. incomplete or lack specific
complete and
inaccurate.
metrics or
include
measurable
specific
determinants
metrics or
and relevant
measurable
details.
determinants
and relevant
details.
methods for
determining the
success of the
change
initiative are
extremely
thorough with
specific metrics
or measurable
determinants
clearly defined
and numerous
relevant details.
Strategies for
Strategies for Strategies for sustaining
sustaining
sustaining
change are
Strategies for
5.0 %
Strategies for
change are
change are
thoroughly
sustaining
Strategies for sustaining
presented, but complete and presented with
change are
Sustaining
change are not
discussion is
include
rich detail and
incomplete or
Change
addressed.
cursory and
discussion of include
inaccurate.
lacking in
all necessary discussion of
depth.
elements.
all necessary
elements.
Discussion of
Discussion of how the change
how the
plan supports
Discussion of Discussion of
change plan the
Discussion of how the change how the change
supports the organizational
how the change plan supports plan supports
organizational mission and
plan supports the
the
mission and goals,
the
organizational organizational
goals,
addresses
organizational mission and
mission and
addresses
stakeholder
5.0 % Overall mission and
goals,
goals, addresses
stakeholder
concerns, and
Effectiveness of goals, addresses addresses
stakeholder
concerns, and contributes to
Change Plan stakeholder
stakeholder
concerns, and
contributes to the community
concerns, and concerns, and contributes to
the community of society is
contributes to contributes to the community
of society is thoroughly
the community the community of society is
presented and presented with
of society is not of society is
cursory and
includes
rich detail and
included.
incomplete or lacking in
discussion of includes
inaccurate.
depth.
all necessary discussion of
elements.
all necessary
elements.
13.0
%Organization
and
Effectiveness
3.0 % Thesis
Development
and Purpose
Paper lacks any Thesis is
discernible
insufficiently
overall purpose developed or
or organizing vague. Purpose
claim.
is not clear.
Thesis is
apparent and
appropriate to
purpose.
Thesis is clear
and forecasts Thesis is
the
comprehensive
development and contains
of the paper. the essence of
Thesis is
the paper.
descriptive and Thesis
reflective of statement
the arguments makes the
and
purpose of the
appropriate to paper clear.
the purpose.
13.0
%Organization
and
Effectiveness
5.0 %
Argument
Logic and
Construction
Argument is
orderly, but may
have a few
Argument
inconsistencies.
Sufficient
shows logical
Statement of
The argument
justification of
progressions. Clear and
purpose is not
presents
claims is
Techniques of convincing
justified by the
minimal
lacking.
argumentation argument that
conclusion. The
justification of
Argument lacks
are evident. presents a
conclusion does
claims.
consistent
There is a
persuasive
not support the
Argument
unity. There are
smooth
claim in a
claim made.
logically, but
obvious flaws
progression of distinctive and
Argument is
not thoroughly,
in the logic.
claims from compelling
incoherent and
supports the
Some sources
introduction to manner. All
uses
purpose.
have
conclusion.
sources are
noncredible
Sources used
questionable
Most sources authoritative.
sources.
are credible.
credibility.
are
Introduction and
authoritative.
conclusion
bracket the
thesis.
13.0
%Organization
and
Effectiveness
5.0 %
Surface errors Frequent and
Mechanics of are pervasive repetitive
Writing
enough that
mechanical
(includes
they impede
errors distract
spelling,
communication the reader.
Some
mechanical
errors or typos
are present, but
they are not
Prose is
The writer is
largely free of clearly in
mechanical
command of
errors,
standard,
although a few written,
punctuation, of meaning.
grammar, and Inappropriate
language use) word choice or
sentence
construction is
employed.
Inconsistencies overly
in language
distracting to
choice
the reader.
(register) or
Correct and
word choice are varied sentence
present.
structure and
Sentence
audiencestructure is
appropriate
correct but not language are
varied.
employed.
may be
academic
present. The English.
writer uses a
variety of
effective
sentence
structures and
figures of
speech.
7.0 %Format
Appropriate
Appropriate
Appropriate
Template is not template is
2.0 % Paper
template is
template is
used
used, but some
Format (use of
used.
fully used.
appropriately or elements are
All format
appropriate
Formatting is There are
documentation missing or
elements are
style for the
correct,
virtually no
format is rarely mistaken. A
correct.
major and
although some errors in
followed
lack of control
assignment)
minor errors
formatting
correctly.
with formatting
may be present. style.
is apparent.
5.0 %
Documentation
Documentation
Sources are
of sources is Sources are
of Sources
Sources are completely and
inconsistent or documented, as
(citations,
documented, correctly
incorrect, as
appropriate to
footnotes,
as appropriate documented, as
Sources are not appropriate to assignment and
references,
to assignment appropriate to
documented. assignment and style, although
bibliography,
and style, and assignment and
style, with
some formatting
etc., as
format is
style, and
numerous
errors may be
appropriate to
mostly correct. format is free
formatting
present.
assignment and
of error.
errors.
style)
100 % Total
Weightage
Purchase answer to see full
attachment