Reflecting on US presidents
I think you will find this quite interesting. First,
this is a poll taken in 2000 of major scholars in law, politics, and
history, chosen from both sides of the political spectrum, ranking and
rating US presidents up to that point in time.
There is another poll of historians done frequently
by Sienna College and I find it interesting because it gives presidents
a ranking in 20 different categories. As you can see, none of the categories is explicitly a political category. Some are innate capacities like intelligence or imagination. Others are skills like relating to Congress. This is from their 2010 poll:
So, based upon these two studies and the presidents we have specifically studied this quarter, discuss one ranking you agree with and why; one ranking you disagree with and why; and one ranking that surprised you and why.
Be sure to base your replies on historical evidence
and not just on personal opinion, and be civil to your classmates even
if you disagree with their choices. Also
remember that our class didn’t start until 1865, so if you want to
discuss earlier presidents you may need to do additional research.