Write a minimum 300 word paper addressing:
- What are the issues raised in this case?
- How important do you believe these issues are?
- What course of action would you have taken? Please explain.
Paper must follow the APA standards regarding formatting, citation, and references.Case Study:
Tom Peterson is an industrial sales
representative for J&R Company, a large company in the pipe, valve, and fitting
industry. J&R Company serves customers with facilities in which gases or
liquids are moved from one place to another in the manufacturing process. Tom
returned to his office from visiting a large potential customer in the paper
and pulp industry. During his drive, Tom decided to call his weekly golf
partner Sam McNeil, a reporter for the trade publication for Tom’s industry.
Tom planned to ask Sam to run a story about his company’s new product and the
two largest companies that Tom believed would soon sign a contract with J&R
to purchase the product. J&R Company had developed a new valve system that
they believed would reduce spills and leaks in customers’ manufacturing
facilities. However, the product was slow to take off in the market. While
J&R’s system was shown to reduce leaks by 0.4 percent (0.5 percent with the
additional purchase of an extended service contract), Tom believed those reports
significantly underestimated the value of the system. Valve leak detection
systems had become extremely popular in manufacturing facilities in recent
Tom sensed that the product was
slow-moving on the market because companies felt that the leak detection
systems were more cost-effective than purchasing a completely new valve system
and stopping production while the new system was installed. Earlier in the day,
Tom had visited one of his company’s largest prospective customers—Biddle Inc.,
a major pulp and paper company. Tom told Biddle Inc. that one of its closest
competitors would soon begin using J&R’s new valve system. While Biddle
Inc.’s competitor had not yet signed a contract or committed to J&R, Tom
felt that they soon would come round and agree to purchase the system as well
as the extended service contract. Tom offered Biddle Inc. a low price on the
initial system. He knew the initial system would be obsolete in the next year
as the company refined the system and significantly decreased its spill/leakage
rate. But Tom felt that if Biddle Inc. agreed to buy the initial system, they
would see how well the product performed and naturally upgrade to the refined
system once it was placed on the market. Tom explained to Biddle Inc. that the
new system substantially reduced the risk of leaks and spills, which slow down
production and are costly. Tom built his sales presentation around the costs of
leaks or spills across all industries in which liquids and gas are somehow
processed. He mentioned several times in his sales presentation that as
compared to purchasing the new valve system only, purchasing the extended
service contract would offer Biddle Inc. a 20 percent reduction in the spill
rate. Tom hoped that if Sam, his golfing partner, would help him with media
coverage for J&R’s new valve system, the product might start to pick up
some momentum on the market. He planned to use coverage of the story as an
additional lever to close the deals with Biddle Inc. and its competitor. While
neither potential customer had committed, and both frankly told Tom they had
serious reservations about the new product, Tom thought a product review
published in a respected trade publication would offer the product the
credibility it needed to jump-start sales. In any case, Sam owed Tom a favor.
If the valve system did not do well in the market during the next quarter,
J&R had made clear that the company would be forced to downsize its sales
force. The company had an extended line of products and services, and while senior
management hoped the new valve system would become a flagship product for the
company, they would not sacrifice the reputation of their other products in
attempts to force a lackluster product to market. Tom has worked for J&R
for ten years. Nevertheless, he felt his job was vulnerable. He had shifted his
sales emphasis entirely to the new valve system, giving up territory and
smaller customers who purchased other products and services from the company.
In Tom’s city, industrial sales positions were limited. With two children—one
in high school, the other in middle school—and a wife with a secure position at
a large law firm in the area, Tom did not welcome the prospects of job change.
He had to find a way to make the new valve system a marketplace success.