Rubric for Case Studies - MBA Elizabethtown College Criteria Identification of the main issues and/or problems. Requirements 3-5 issues and/or problems. Weight 10% Literature research Majority (at least 60% or higher) of & review. articles and/or references must be within last 10 years. 15% Analysis of the key All issues must be analyzed. issues. 25% Provide method of comparison between alternatives. Include short-term Observations and long-term and/or recommendations recommendations; Included should be on effective realistic time solutions. frames, designation of roles and responsibilities of all stakeholders and an appropriate evaluation program. Includes overall Writing Skills/Professional composition, structure, grammar, Presentation. spelling, and punctuation. 20% Alternative solutions and/or options. Score Distinguished/ Excellent (4) Proficient/Good (3) Identifies and understands Identifies and all the main issues in the understands most of the case study. main issues in the case study. Excellent research with Good research and clearly documented documented associations between associations between problems or questions and problems or questions key course concepts and and key course concepts good (3 or more) use of and some (2 or more) corroborating sources. use of corroborating sources. Insightful and thorough Insightful and thorough analysis of all the key analysis of most of the issues. key issues. Alternatives cover all the Alternatives cover most key issues with method to of the key issues with method to evaluate. evaluate all equally. 20% Well-reasoned, logical, relevant observations and recommendations on effective solutions to most of the problems/issues. Solid, well-thought out observations and recommendations on effective solutions to many of the problems/issues. 10% Writing is totally free of grammar and spelling errors. Clear, concise and creative presentation of ideas and properly referenced. There are few spelling or grammatical errors. Most ideas are clearly presented and references are used. Basic/Fair (2) NonPerformance/Poor (0) Identifies and Identifies and understands some of understands few of the the main issues in the main issues in the case case study. study. Limited research and Incomplete research associations between and associations the problems or between the problems questions and key or questions and key course concepts and course concepts and little (1 or more) use no use of of corroborating corroborating sources. sources. Insightful and thorough Incomplete analysis of analysis of some of the key issues. the key issues. Alternatives cover Incomplete analysis of some of the key alternatives with no issues with method to evaluation method. evaluate. Shallow observations Superficial and recommendations observations and on effective solutions recommendations on effective solutions to a to some of the few of the problems/issues. problems/issues. There are several spelling or grammatical errors. Some ideas are clearly presented. References are sporadic or not used. There are many spelling errors and grammatical mistakes. Ideas are hard to follow. References are not used. Total Weight Total Assignment (Case Study) Points Case Study Final Score: Criteria Identification of the main issues and/or problems. Literature research & review. Analysis of the key issues. Alternative solutions and/or options. Observations and/or recommendations on effective solutions Writing Skills 100% 0 Comments
Purchase answer to see full attachment