Can you help me understand this question?
The assignment (2–3 pages):
- Given the information in the case study presented and the two different definitions ofinsanity, explain how and why each definition might lead to a different outcome in this case.
- Describe the case you selected from your Internet or Walden Library search and explain how the legal definition of insanity contributed to the verdict.
- Explain what conclusions you can draw about legal definitions and their influence on case outcomes
Week 5 Case Study
One of the
most heinous series of crimes in U.S.
history was uncovered in the state of Wisconsin
in 1991 when Jeffrey Dahmer was arrested for killing as many as 17 men and
young boys over several years. His murders included the sadistic rape, torture,
murder and even cannibalism of some of his victims. It was alleged that Dahmer
drilled holes in some of his victim’s heads while they were alive, but bound
and sedated. He then poured acid into the holes in an attempt to create the
perfect sex slave. His murders ranged in time from 1978 until he was arrested
for his assault on Tracy Edwards, his potential 18th victim. In his apartment
following his arrest, were four human heads, one of which was in the
refrigerator. Also in the apartment were severed hands and penises, multiple
photos of mangled body parts, and other atrocious evidence. Tracy Edwards had
escaped from Dahmer’s apartment and summoned the police. Several corpses were
found stored in a vat of acid. The news of the horrific deeds committed by
Jeffrey Dahmer soon hit the press and had people wondering how anyone in their
right mind could do something like this to another human being. That same
question was posed, albeit in a slightly different fashion, of several forensic
mental health experts before Dahmer’s 2-week trial began in January of 1992. Jeffrey
Dahmer chose to plead “not guilty by reason of insanity.” He was formally
evaluated by mental health experts hired by the defense and the prosecution. Among
the diagnoses given were substance abuse issues and several paraphilias,
including sexual sadism. It was alleged by one of the mental health experts at
trial that, as a sexual sadist, Dahmer could not resist his urges to commit the
crimes for which he was accused. Ultimately, Dahmer was found guilty and
sentenced to 15 life terms. He was murdered by a fellow inmate while serving
his sentence at the Columbia Correctional Institute in Portage, Wisconsin.
Federal Insanity definition
– “…at the time of the commission of the
acts constituting the offense, the defendant, as a result of serious mental
disease or defect, was unable to appreciate the nature and quality or
wrongfulness of his acts. Mental disease or defect does not otherwise
constitute a defense.”
(U.S. Code, Title 18)
American Law Institute’s Model Penal
Code Insanity definition – "A person
is not responsible for criminal conduct if at the time of such conduct as a
result of mental disease or defect he lacks substantial capacity either to
appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the
requirements of the law."