10 page critique and personal reflection on the textbook "Why evolution is true".

User Generated

yvbaxvat1212

Writing

Description

A 10-page critique and personal reflection on the textbook Why Evolution Is True. APA style is required.

Your paper should allow you to reflect upon each of the themes in the chapters of the book. For example, you should focus on reflections of your growing understanding of what evolution is and what it is not. It should include your personal journey of discovery related to the concept of evolution. It should also include philosophical, theological, and sociological reflections, as well as a demonstration of a scientific understanding of evolution. Additionally, you should critique and evaluate the ideas presented in the book using your scientific understanding of the process of evolution.

It also ought to evidence the following:

  • Understanding of the relevant science
  • The ability to use relevant literature in support of your conclusions
  • Your individual response to the material and readings. This may involve an assessment of what you found to be particularly compelling and/or problematic; your personal thoughts and/or reactions to what is being considered; consideration of implications implicit in the materials being addressed; an assessment of the strengths and/or shortcomings of particular points; etc.

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool's honor code & terms of service.

Explanation & Answer

Attached.

Running head: CRITIQUE AND PERSONAL REFLECTION

Critique and Personal Reflection
Name
Institution

1

CRITIQUE AND PERSONAL REFLECTION

2

Critique and Personal Reflection
Why Evolution is True – Jerry. A. Coyne
In his book Why Evolution is True, Jerry. A. Coyne highlights instances of the empirical
evidence of evolution according to Darwin. Apparently, there are debates on the grounds of
creationism versus natural processes as answers to the question of organism existence (Coyne,
2014). The book rather focuses on the gradual build-up of evidence that supports the Darwinian
theory of evolution and natural selection. Therefore, such facts support Coyne’s truth like a
mirror of Darwinism. The book not only explores various fields of science but it also provides a
brilliant explanation of vast proof of evolution. There are common misunderstandings between
staunch believers of creationism and scientists, and I believe that Why Evolution Is True is a
great resource that captures both sides of the controversy as it confirms the processes of change
in living organisms over time (Coyne, 2014). The book shows how creationists who dismiss
evolution by natural selection are ignorant. I believe that Coyne’s pragmatism, transparency, and
extensive comparison creates a great platform for a better understanding of creationism and
evolution as well as the relevance of the latter. People can, therefore, realize which side to be
inclined to by knowledge and not mere beliefs. According to Coyne, the process ceases to be a
theory when it is backed by strong evidence, and it becomes true.
The evidence is the strongest element in Coyne’s exposition. Opponents of the Darwinian
Theory rarely mention evidence in the debate about intelligent design and creationism. Truth is
anything that is based on facts, and his book defends the theory fully with the gradual related
findings over the years. The six components of the modern evolution theory, as Coyne outlines
them, enable the reader to internalize the processes and find logic in their connections to the

CRITIQUE AND PERSONAL REFLECTION

3

existence of organisms (Coyne, 2014). The components are the genetic aspect of evolution,
gradualism, speciation, common ancestry, natural selection, and the processes that instigate
evolutionary change. Why Evolution Is True appreciates the proven evolutionary pressures that
contribute towards change over time. The commonalities of species are apparent in the book and
Coyne guides the reader towards the realization of pressures that caused the split into different
lineages (Coyne, 2014). The six components justify evolution as an actual occurrence as seen in
the availability of decisive evidence.
It is impressive how there is an overwhelming presentation of evolutionary evidence in
Coyne’s book. He explains the process of natural selection successfully by exploring various
fields of science such as the vestigial structure aspect in modern organisms, embryology, fossil
records, suboptimal natural designs, and biogeography as a demonstration of the evolution of
organisms. The findings in these areas of study make the predictions of evolutionary theory
successful because they decipher inexplicable data that was realized earlier by researchers.
Coyne joins the chains of inference making the book a strong resource as he explains the validity
of the evidence (Coyne, 2014). Therefore, biologists have no choice but to accept the main
modern evolutionary theory propositions. From a social point of view, it is not easy to come to
terms with the fact that different species share a common ancestry and their forms in the present
are as a result of split lineages in the past. However, one can visualize their ways of adaptation
through the Coyne’s account and affirmation of natural selection.
The controversy about the theory of evolution can only linger on social grounds but not
on a scientific basis. In fact, with the evidence in the book, scientists should stop adding the word
“theory” to evolution realization. Science is a subject that is governed by research, and findings
and the professional discussions of evolution at this point show that there is ...


Anonymous
Really useful study material!

Studypool
4.7
Trustpilot
4.5
Sitejabber
4.4

Related Tags