A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man
James Joyce
Contributed by Cinderella Domino
Get 24/7
Homework help
Our tutors provide high quality explanations & answers.
Post question

Newest Questions

Chapter 3
Summary

Being brought up in a God-fearing Roman Catholic home, Stephen will be well aware that his liaison with the prostitute marks the point where he committed his “first violent sin”. This sets him on the road to debauchery and his sexual appetite is now matched by his quest for food, meat, carrots and potatoes. He now succumbs to temptation and acts against his strict upbringing.  He leads a double life in that he still serves as Prefect for the Sodality of the Blessed Virgin Mary. This is a statue of the Virgin and is a refuge for sinners. Stephen is well aware of his hypocrisy, which is heightened by the fact that he still attends his catechism classes.

As well as the sins of lust and gluttony, he indulges in the other deadly sins of anger, pride, envy, sloth and avarice.

Just when there seems to be no hope for Stephen, he learns of a three day Spiritual Retreat that is being organized at Belvedere to honor the school’s Patron Saint, Francis Xavier.  On the first day of the Retreat, Father Arnall gives a sermon based on Judgement Day, his text coming from Ecclesiasticus Ch.7 v.36. The sermon is designed to make an impact on those present and coupled with Stephen’s imagination, he is able to vividly see Father Arnall’s described scene. Father Arnall emphasizes that everyone should ensure that they are prepared for life after death in case this suddenly happens and they might find themselves damned.  The Father’s words seem to haunt Stephen and he feels guilty about his recent sinful behavior. He feels that every word of the sermon is directed straight at him. Stephen regrets the actions he had taken concerning his childhood “love” Emma. He had composed fictitious letters concerning Emma, which were obscene and left them in a place where any unknown girl might find them.

The second day at the Retreat, the sermon given to those present concerned Isaiah Ch.5 v.14 and Father Arnall describes how hell is always seeking to enlarge its domain.  It seeks all those that are sinful. It seeks Stephen. Stephen is intrigued by the story of the once-favored angel Lucifer who due to his pride is cast into everlasting darkness. The sermon goes on to illustrate how mankind’s nature can so easily be tempted by sin and that is what led to Adam and Eve being cast out of the Garden of Eden. It was Jesus Christ, through the crucifixion that took on the sins of the world.  It is important that man should repent of his sins and confess them. Again Stephen’s imagination is working overtime as he imagines the endless torment awaiting those who are bent on hell. The sermon is aimed at describing the torments of hell through the senses, hearing, smell, touch and sight. What frightens Stephen most is being confined in a cramped situation being suffocated by the bodies around him in the fiery furnaces of hell.  However, hell is more than just physical torture; it is also being separated from God’s love. At the end of the sermon, Stephen is horrified and his sense of guilt has increased. In an almost panic state, he realizes his need to be saved. He can be saved if he makes his confession, but through shame he cannot do this in the College Chapel.

Father Arnall’s sermon on Day 3 of the Retreat follows on from the first two, and his text comes from Psalms 30, v.23. He now describes the spiritual pain of hell. He tells those in attendance that Satan has a three-pronged attack on the sinners he receives. The sinner will see his past pleasures with repulsion, secondly he will see himself as God sees him, and thirdly he will be given enlightenment, which reveals that because he did not repent, he must suffer eternal damnation.

After this final sermon, Stephen analyses what he has heard and concludes that he is lost due to the magnitude of his sins.  He must obtain absolution through confession and so he leaves the College to find a Chapel outside. This he does and he receives his absolution from an old Capuchin. This Priest gives Stephen his penance and advises him to seek help from the Blessed Virgin to overcome his temptation. Stephen is elated and feels that he is in a state of grace.

Next day he takes Holy Communion and vows to begin a new life of obedience and service to God.

Analysis

Following on from Chapter 2, the start of Chapter 3 deals with Stephen’s sinfulness and his association with the Dublin prostitutes.  “The whores would be just coming out of their houses making ready for the night, yawning lazily after their sleep and settling the hairpins in their clusters of hair. He would pass by them calmly waiting for a sudden movement of his own will or a sudden call to his sin loving soul from their soft perfumed flesh.”  This section together with the last paragraph of Chapter 2 shows how Joyce’s use of words can conjure up a scene. Here it is the dark world of the prostitute that is examined and while the words in themselves are not sordid, the passage as a whole conjures up the atmosphere and Stephen’s desire to be engulfed by it.

Stephen submits himself to this sinful world.  His lusting after the prostitutes increases his appetite, and he becomes a glutton.  He now seems quicker to anger, and his overall behavior spreads into the other deadly sins – avarice, pride, envy, sloth.  This degeneration slowly drains his whole spirit and his whole being.

Stephen is thrown a lifeline to escape from this existence when he hears of the 3 Day Spiritual Retreat. During this time, Stephen will hear three sermons, based on Ecclesiastes Ch.7, Isaiah Ch.5, and Psalm 30. All three texts are from the Old Testament and we can well imagine the Bible thumping Father Arnall instilling fear on his captured congregation describing the fire and brimstone of hell.  The design of the sermons is to awaken even the dullard, so the impact on Stephen with his vivid imagination is striking. His recent sins are all too fresh in his mind.

In Ecclesiastes Chapter 7, we read, “The wiles of a woman I find mightier than death; her heart is a trap to catch you and her arms are fetters.  The man who is pleasing to God may escape her, but she will catch a sinner.” Stephen will feel that he has been caught through the sin of lust and his behavior will be well known to God.

In Isaiah Chapter 5, we read, “Shame on you! You who rise to go in pursuit of liquor and draw out the evening inflamed with wine, at whose feasts there are harp and lute, tabor and pipe and wine, who have no eyes for the work of the Lord, and never see the things that he has done’’ but the Lord of Hosts sits high in judgement.”  This follows on from the previous text. This whole section of Isaiah deals with the shame in being a sinner and Stephen feels this shame directly. He needs to confess, but cannot do so in the College Chapel and finds a more discreet place in which to obtain forgiveness.

The final sermon is based on Psalm 30, where we read of the joy of a sinner repentant and lifted up from those who are to go down into the abyss.  “O Lord thou has brought me up from Sheol and saved my life as I was sinking into the abyss’’ Thou hast turned my laments into dancing; thou has stripped off my sackcloth and clothed me with joy that my spirit may sing psalms to Thee and never cease.”  Stephen’s spiritual state at present is such that he will fall into the abyss and suffer the physical torments of hell and will know of the joy of heaven, but will never be able to experience it.

Stephen is resolved to obtain a state of grace by receiving absolution for his sins.  He gets this by seeking out an old kindly Capuchin Cleric who seems rather off-hand about Stephen’s sins.  No doubt the locality of his Chapel in Church Street means that he will not be shocked by the level of Stephen’s sinfulness, and the penance he gives Stephen will not match the penance Stephen imposes on himself later on. Stephen will wonder whether he has received true absolution later as he appears to have gone for the easy option in not seeking absolution from one of his own Priests.

From Chapter 1 we were aware of Stephen’s sensitivity and how he perceived the world through his senses.  Like Joyce, we know that Stephen had problems with his eyesight and this will have enhanced his other senses. Coupled with Stephen’s imagination he is assaulted by the imagery described by Father Arnall through his sermons.  By the end of these three days, Stephen can smell, hear, feel the pain, and see what is in store for those that are damned to Lucifer’s realm. We are reminded of Lucifer’s downfall and Stephen parallels his own possible fate to that of Lucifer.

Stephen can save himself and he is guided in this by the Capuchin Cleric who directs him towards the Blessed Virgin.  She represents the softer side of God who is depicted by Father Arnall as a vengeful, fearsome God. Joyce is making the point that the tone of the sermons is extreme and he is making a direct criticism of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland in that it does not give enough emphasis to the God of love.  Even when reference is made to Jesus, it is not as a bringer of peace, but as one who suffered pain on the cross in order to bring salvation to mankind.

The reader may think that Stephen has over-reacted, but he is only 16 years of age and still feels quite vulnerable even though he enjoys some degree of importance at Belvedere College. In fact he would normally be a role model for the younger boys and this is another aspect that makes Stephen feel guilty.  Although he continues to be a somewhat solitary figure, he still recognizes that he has some responsibility to his fellow students.

There had always been a special place in his heart for Emma, but we learn that he desecrated his image of her by concocting letters regarding her of a sordid nature.  He had left these in a place where a young girl might find them. The relevance of this incident and others is that they parallel similar events in the young Joyce’s life.  When Joyce was apart from Nora Barnacle he wrote a series of “foul long letters”, which survived despite Nora’s efforts to destroy them. In Ellman’s biography of Joyce he suggests that the contents of these letters provide an insight into Joyce’s literary treatment of women.

It is evident that the fear of God was instilled into Joyce by the Priests of the Jesuit Schools, which resulted in Joyce’s own image of hell, which is recounted in this book.  Like Stephen, Joyce has acute senses and these were accosted by the imagery that God is a fearful God and not a God of love. Rightly or wrongly, Joyce vents his criticism of the Roman Catholic Church he has had experience of.

Joyce does not wish to lay bare his own soul, so it is up to the reader to decide how much of Joyce is in Stephen and vice-versa.

In the end, Joyce is stating that it is not the degradation of the human spirit through sin, nor the physical and psychological tortures of hell that is the factor in making Stephen confess his sins, but the fact that if he remains unrepentant, he will be forever removed from God’s divine presence.  However, this is not the God of vengeance, but the God of love.

The Chapter concludes with Stephen’s rededication to a life without sin.

info_outline
Have study documents to share about A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man? Upload them to earn free Studypool credits!